This year, I resolve to ban laptops from my classroom
washingtonpost.com
washingtonpost.com
Personally I used mine for a lot of rapid note-taking, which was a lot faster for me than having to write things down. It actually allowed me to take notes in real time which I am not able to do on paper. Then I also encountered a professor like the one in the submitted article who hated the idea of students using the devices the school encouraged them to buy for their education in his classroom. That class was the roughest for me, I found it very hard to work with my written notes (Which I no longer was used to using of course, since I used that laptop for years) and am convinced the class would have gone a lot better for me had the professor not decided to make a decision which set his classroom starkly apart from the rest.
If the school has a policy of allowing laptops then I think it's terrible for a professor to override that.
I hand write notes in meetings and I use Cornell method. For me personally I don't think a computer would work (partly because I only type at about 65 WPM) so I'm interested when I find people who say it does work for them.
If he's going to ban laptops, I hope he refrains from reading off powerpoint slides. Any professor or teacher who does has given up their right to be mad if students aren't paying attention.
It comes down to motivation. Laptops in the classroom are a nearly irresistible demotivator/distractor for most kids.
I think there are always people who will do something else, if they were not looking at a laptop they'd be daydreaming or idly doodling. In the end it doesn't matter as long as they can do the work and meet the learning goals of the course. The ones who can't, regardless of whether they're looking at a laptop, will (or should...) fail anyway.
Disclosure: I work for Frog, a company that creates learning platforms.
Are you talking about "learning styles" such as kinaesthetic or visual or auditory?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Learning_styles
> Although there is ample evidence that individuals express preferences for how they prefer to receive information, few studies have found any validity in using learning styles in education.[2] Critics say there is no evidence that identifying an individual student's learning style produces better outcomes. There is evidence of empirical and pedagogical problems related to the use of learning tasks to "correspond to differences in a one-to-one fashion."[3] Well-designed studies contradict the widespread "meshing hypothesis", that a student will learn best if taught in a method deemed appropriate for the student's learning style.[2]
In other words, if your students are staring at Facebook maybe is because your lecture is boring as hell. That's what you should be worried about.
Maybe or maybe not, it's not surprising that all teaching material isn't always as immediately rewarding as checking facebook.
The learning process will be similar to 20, 200 or 2000 years ago as the brain does not change that quickly. The mode by which we access things to learn may well change from generation to generation.
Challenge: 'boring' may imply resistance to engagement, perhaps because the material is hard.
Yet the students, who have grown up in an interactive digital world, learn differently. Schooled on Google and Wikipedia, they want to inquire, not rely on the professor for a detailed roadmap. They want an animated conversation, not a lecture. They want an interactive education, not a broadcast one that might have been perfectly fine for the Industrial Age, or even for boomers. These students are making new demands of universities, and if the universities try to ignore them, they will do so at their peril.
http://edge.org/conversation/the-impending-demise-of-the-uni...
Given the excerpt you quoted uses the word "want" I think you mean you don't want to learn in a broadcast way. That's fine, but that's not a sufficient rebuttal to the point you were replying to that "The learning process will be similar to 20, 200 or 2000 years ago as the brain does not change that quickly." I'm not sure I entirely agree with that[1], but saying you want to learn in a different way is not evidence that "people learn in totally different ways."
On one hand I feel students preferring more interaction / less broadcast is nothing new, but on the other hand the popularity of Coursera, MIT OpenCourseWare, Udacity, Khan Academy, and countless other very "broadcasty" education sites/resources would seem to indicate many are quite satisfied with little or no interaction.
[1] http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2008/07/is-googl...
Before every class I used to read the contents we were going to cover (superficial read). That way I wouldn't be caught by weird words, references or concepts. At least I knew something. Then I'd "use" the professor to "explain" and "dig" those concepts for me.
If you seriously need to take notes, the one failing is the professor. She/he should provide the content covered in the class in the form of pages of books to read, slides, etc.
If you're a student. DON'T TAKE NOTES! (again, just my opinion)
I was going through old books from university over christmas. I found two notebooks where I took extensive notes during class.
They were all familiar. I remembered the content of the class quite well, whereas I've forgotten most other classes.
(Of course, one possible bias is that I thought these two teachers were better, so I may have paid more attention)