Senate blocks transparency, refuses to put bills online
msnbc.msn.com
msnbc.msn.com
The party of Obama is not Obama's party, it seems.
Lovely debate, can anyone please post it online? :)
* true national security concerns
* personal confidentiality
* any monetary transaction information that might cost the taxpayer money by putting the treasury at a disadvantage in some prospective transaction.
Objections? What am I missing?
I think having every report written by the government posted online could potentially make it difficult to be honest in the reports.
If a part of the government is commissioned to write a report, and they do honest researchand come to a controversial conclusion (e.g. something about a particular race), what happens if it goes online? People who find out about it will get angry at that part of the government (e.g. call them racist). With that in mind, I'd imagine they might write something less controversial but less honest.
In the abstract, I agree with you, everything possible should be posted online. But until people respond to things reasonably, I don't know that it is feasible.
I guess its worth pointing out that I'm not sure where I stand on this... as below, I'm sort of playing devil's advocate.
Edit: Spelling, grammer.
I also have some concerns about full transparency, just on the general basis that "the best laid plans..." often "gang aft aglay". But all bills should be posted online, where they can be easily found and searched, at least a week before the vote takes place. No ands, ifs, or buts.
I'd also love to see time reports of our hard working public servants. You can discover a lot by softing through the details.
>> I think having every report written by the government posted online could potentially make it difficult to be honest in the reports.
Yes. Not sure what to do about that.
Slightly OT, but I would love to see a law that requires every scientific paper that used public funding be posted online, for free, within a year of dead tree publication.
I think the necessary action is some sort of education program (yeah, yeah, it'll never happen, I know...). If we can somehow educate people to never get mad at a fact (a quote from a political science textbook I read once) then we might be able to do this.
In any event, I think this sort of education is necessary because as things stand, reports are often treated as opinions, which is bad.
Edit: Slightly OT, but I would love to see a law that requires every scientific paper that used public funding be posted online, for free, within a year of dead tree publication.
Its a interesting idea, but we'd need to find a way to compensate journals. I think they get boatloads of money from academic institutions paying for access to their publications (correct me if I'm wrong).
Coburn may be a Republican, but I think this is an issue that transcends party affiliations. In this case, you're either in favor of transparency or you're in favor of backroom deal-cutting. It's unfortunate that Coburn is being left to hang over it.
provision requiring reports that agencies are required to send to the appropriations panels be made available to other lawmakers and to the public.
This provision doesn't seem to require that potential bills be posted online but that all reports be put online. I don’t think it’s unreasonable to assume that if someone wants to write a report with a controversial but accurate conclusion, they might decide not to if its going to be public.
Unfortunately, privacy is often necessary for honesty.
I think this is an issue that transcends party affiliations
I agree. Edit: However, for HN, I hope we can keep party politics out of this.
you're either in favor of transparency or you're in favor of backroom deal-cutting.
I'd agree with this to some degree if the provision said something like "any bills that are proposed to be voted on and all ammendments, etc... should be posted online." In any event, I'm not convinced that anyhthing will change the way laws are made. If the rule is "anything official needs to be posted online" then more will go through unofficial channels and we'll still be in the dark.
That being said, I wish I had a better way to truly increase transparency.