What We Lose If We Lose the Canon
chronicle.com
chronicle.com
What an absurd statement. "The dismantling of hierarchies is tantamount to an erasure of history"?
No, no.
The danger of the canon is that it presents its status as self-evident, obvious, a birthright. "Of course these texts are foundational, and should be." A canon isn't just a group of texts that are good; it's a group of texts and ideas that try to place themselves outside of the realm of judgment by presenting themselves as near-holy.
It should go without saying; there can be many different groups of good things for different people, many different preferences. Wanting to preserve pre-existing hierarchies without changing it is one of the most oppressive things I can imagine.
Cultures tend to reshape their canonical lists to suit current tastes, preferences, and philosophical goals. "The Canon" is a much less fixed and immovable object than people commonly imagine it to be. This, in and of itself, is another flaw in the argument that "The Canon" should be preserved at all costs. Which canon? Which version?
Now we teach Hawthorne and mediocre literature because they were part of the American canon. However, they were included because we didn't have a lot of other options.