I don't understand the conclusion, given the points. It's a very pessimistic essay about the future, where all air travel is horrible and nobody will want to fly. I don't buy it.
I don't understand the conclusion, given the points. It's a very pessimistic essay about the future, where all air travel is horrible and nobody will want to fly. I don't buy it.
1. Concorde was on the verge of being replaced by a more efficient Model B version, which was quieter and cheaper to run. That was on the drawing board in the 1970s. Model C, D, E versions would have been cheaper and even more cost effective.
2. Concorde was actually killed by anticompetitive US politics. The story is too complex to detail here, but it's not a mystery in the aerospace biz.
3. If Stross thinks bizjets kill airliners, what's to stop the development of a hypersonic bizjet to give buyers the best of all possible worlds, and also provide the ultimate status symbol for those who care about such things?
4. Trrrrism? This part can be ignored, because the argument is silly.
5. Energy cost remains an issue. But if you're in the (literally) stratospheric biz set, you're not going to care about that.
6. Telepresence may kill some of the market, because I'm guessing 15 years from now it's going to be impressively immersive. But for some applications, including highly secure negotiations and ultra-speedy courier services, there's still no substitute for being there.
So in fact there's a perfectly viable, if innovative, business case, and the technology is looking at least potentially feasible.
I wouldn't be surprised to see these services running before 2030.
Together those three were what caused the towel to be thrown into the ring. Every time I visit Paris and I see it impaled on its stand it reminds me of a butterfly or something trying to escape. Such a sad image.
Yeah, congress only banned SSTs and supersonic civilian flight right as concorde came online, that can't have had any impact on it.
America has often used sly tactics to crush superior British technology.
It's no coincidence it's main routes (London->JFK, Paris ->JFK) are 90% over the Ocean.
If you actually managed to get long distance hypersonic routes (such as London->Sydney, or even London->Beijing, London->Tokyo, etc.) at a significant time reduction, I can see it working.
1. re: First class dying. The reason is that, aside from some of the really high-end international options on e.g. Emirates, business class has effectively become first class. In general, today's business class accommodations are significantly better than first class in the old days with lie flat seats and personal entertainment systems.
2. Concorde was always pretty much a niche market. Saving a few hours in a comfortable first class seat is not a big win for just about anyone unless you're a high-priced lawyer doing an out and back to London for a day.
To put things into perspective, Bombardier have 243 net orders for the CSeries (an aircraft comparable in size if not capability) before the aircraft has been certified for commercial use. And the programme - involving comparatively simple technological innovation - isn't considered particularly commercially successful.
Yes, the US government's decision to limit its ability to operate in US airspace didn't help Concorde. And neither did the equivalent Soviet airliner spectacularly exploding at an air show. Or rising fuel costs. But what reason does any madman with enough billions to get a hypothetical hypersonic aircraft built and certified for commercial operations have to think that the same won't happen again?
The thing with rockets and jets and the like is that they aren't going to rapidly improve, they are fundamentally limited by chemistry and simple hydrocarbons are incredibly energy dense.
He assumes that technologically it will be practical, perhaps to a point that it's comparable to existing prices for high-end seats on a plane.
Even so, he points out that the security risks mean that it will never happen from existing airports, and that any time saved on suborbital flight will be used up taking the train back to the major city.
He gives a real-world example of the Concorde intercontinental routes being ditched... they didn't make enough money.
Rich people who can afford this want to go to LA and New York and Paris. Not New Mexico, rural Maine, and Scotland.
> It's a very pessimistic essay about the future, where all air travel is horrible and nobody will want to fly. I don't buy it.
Have you flown recently?
Then comes down to the other point, who does most of the traveling anyway? Those with the money and the time to do so. Hence why I would scoff as much at the LA to SF bullet trains as at hypersonic passenger planes. Neither will be cheap enough for the average person to just hop on and the average person probably doesn't have all that free time not already assigned out to use them. Getting somewhere faster is meaningless when you don't have the time to be there.
As for the terrorism angle, until you remove the ability to pilot the vehicle on board it always a possibility, more hollywood than fact though
I spend most of my time in meetings or calls and there is always a certain awkwardness that comes with not being in the same room, people are a lot less warm and you lose the little interactions that make us relate to each other.
On the other hand, I hate spending weeks in-between airports, and any kind of technology initiatives that improve long-distance travel sound great to me. There's definitely a market for this.
I might be alone, but I like that policy.
First off flight times are gate to gate (not airport to airport) so while the flight time is known and quantifiable there are a great many "ground issues" which are not. For example, the gate's motor malfunctions, push-back is delayed (while they "manually" move the gate back), and the aircraft misses its take-off slot.
The nice part about building in 10 minutes extra is that worst case scenario you arrive EARLY and you have to kick around for 10 minutes. Best case, you arrive on the stated time and your expectations are met.
Regardless this seems win/win. They're better meeting or exceeding your expectations more of the time, and the only cost is that you aren't able to min/max your travel quite to the same extent (e.g. build in even shorter transfers between flights).
Currently the minimum authorised transfer window is around 30 minutes for most airlines. While at some airports 30 minutes is fine (Dallas) at others it is terrible (Chicago). Arriving on time in the latter type of airports is a "must" if you want to make your second flight at all.
Are you sure about that? Landing from orbit consists mostly of deceleration. If you manage to skip that, it's as dangerous as a meteorite. Fuel tanks are not needed when you have sheer kinetic energy.
1) slow enough to be relatively safe
or
2) fast enough to cause disintegration of a craft designed for atmosphere re-entry.
I have no aerospace knowledge, so in the absence of anyone doing the maths, I'm going to go with "maybe so, maybe not".