But if you are a founder, a million dollars is probably the best deal for you, and your people, and you should grab it with both hands. Numbers made up but you get the idea.
But if you are a founder, a million dollars is probably the best deal for you, and your people, and you should grab it with both hands. Numbers made up but you get the idea.
If you've not advised a large number of fledgling startups, you wouldn't know, but really truly talking to corpdev is demoralizing and dangerous. If they really want you they'll reach out with an dollar figure (albiet probably a low one). If they haven't done that, they aren't serious. Don't waste your time.
If actually you've raised from a VC, a small acquisition means you'll not clear preferences, which means you get nothing other than retention. The VC/founder conflict only comes up when you have a medium successful company that could be really successful. But in that case you can almost certainly sell secondary stock, lock in your $1 million today, and still go for it.
But more than that, YC (and Paul) truly want to support the founders whatever they want. We celebrate the small sales as well as the big ones. It's simply not true this is selfish advise that you should disregard.
I seem to remember this as a discussion some years ago - where YC was set against the "keep them hungry" mentality. I am assuming it has not changed?
There used to be a widespread belief in the VC world that you wanted to prevent founders from seeing any cash until the ultimate exit. As negotiating leverage has shifted towards founders this has gone away.
It's stupid anyway, since allowing founders to see a little cash up front actually aligns incentives much better once the company is somewhat successful.
As pg said in the essay, the company making the offer got big enough to be an acquirer by resisting the urge to sell before they could achieve their full potential. They would like nothing more than to profit from others who lack the fortitude to do the same thing. Because the acquiring founders have been in those same shoes themselves, they know how appealing a million dollars can sound to a weary entrepreneur and they know what buttons to push. Do not give them what they want!
The numbers in your example are made up, and they can never really be known with certainty. The trajectory of a startup can change with one phone call. There's no way to know whether it's really a 10% chance at a $1MM or a 3% chance at $2.3B or a 7.8% chance at $10MM at any given point in time. When so much is in doubt, it probably makes sense to err on the side of a belief in yourself and what you honestly feel that you can accomplish. Don't sell yourself short just because there's money on the table. That's what I took away from this well written and insightful essay, at least.
And finally, this whole idea of "paul graham is trying to use his essays to manipulate founders into decisions that will benefit him financially" is silly and needs to stop. It's good to question the source, and to understand the motivations of those who give advice. But if there's anyone who has rightly earned a reputation for genuinely helping startup founders and generally doing the right thing, it's pg. He just doesn't want to see good people make the wrong decisions.
PG's quote about the offers only being surprisingly low is correct, from what I can tell.
>> Khosla stated it simply: Google was willing to sell for under a million dollars, but Excite didn’t want to buy them.
It's hard to know, but I have a hard time imagining Google taking over Excite and taking the same trajectory that it did as an independent company.
Expected value of a company with a 1% chance at a billion dollars: $10,000,000
100% chance of a million dollars: $1,000,000
10% chance of a billion dollars: $100,000,000
In which case I would go with the 10% chance because if I had run a startup and got it to be worth $1M, and then I fail I can probably make the $1M easy in the next thing I do.
Of course, if your 90% case is to have a job paying 125K/year then the risk is very low. My point wasn't about you personally but the analysis that should go into this sort of calculation.
This decision in it's purest form can be seen on the game show "Deal or No Deal" where they choose between an unknown value in a box and a $ amount from the 'dealer'. Even this simplified version of the problem gets the contestant on edge and they really have to think hard about it, talk to their spouse etc.
Now, if the expected value were awarded at each stage, and had to be reported as taxable income, and losing the show required that the contestant pay back the money but still had to pay the taxes, than that would have a real risk of ruin.
But on the gripping hand, if you want a million dollars, don't start a start-up. If you want something with the expected value of $100,000, DEFINITELY don't start a start-up. If your goal in life is to get $1,000,000 and then you're going to be awfully happy, then for god's sake, go work at Google or Facebook or plenty of other biggish companies with good compensation. You won't get $1,000,000 all in one lump, but you'll get it, and on average, you'll get it sooner than a founder will.
Risk-adverse people should not be starting companies -- it's risky. And people who have made a solid decision to take a risky path should not bitch if their investors would also like the riskier, more profitable path.
If founders and VCs could math, and if the probability estimates had real meaning, you would have to integrate over the probability and profit/loss curves to estimate future value.
Using single numbers like this is just story telling.
However - if you can spare the time, you can also play Corp Dev at their own game and see if you can get a firm offer.
As long as you're careful not to share IP or intelligence, a firm offer will tell you that your startup is worth at least 2-4X as much, could easily be worth 10X as much, and may be worth 100X as much (but probably isn't.)
That's useful information, even if you have no intention of selling.
I see no problem with stringing Corp Dev types along on that basis.
This is funny, so you think the probability distribution curve is discrete?
P(1Mi)=0.1 does not negate P(1Bi)=0.01, quite on the contrary