Superfreakonomics: The Anatomy of Smear
freakonomics.blogs.nytimes.com
freakonomics.blogs.nytimes.com
If you've ever spent substantial time with the press, you'll learn that this happens all the time. If someone feeds you a quote, it's totally OK to say "sounds good" and have them run it. If they feed you a quote and you don't like it, you can say "wait up, that's not right. I'd say [x] instead." Then, sure, you can you say you were misquoted. (You can also decline to OK the fed quote without giving a more accurate one, and it'd be wrong for the journo to run it.)
The reason reporters/bloggers/press use fed quotes is that they're short. People who are experts are fucking terrible at being pithy. Reporters have learned to feed quotes as a coping method when dealing with verbal diarrhea.
The last election cycle had one too many edits to video that made people look better / worse on both sides. Lord only knows how many quotes in print articles got the same treatment.
Caldiera updated his website to correct that carbon dioxide villain issue, but that's not the quote that was fed to him.
Cue the torches and pitchforks...
It is about science, not politics.
First make a decent scientific point, then make statements like "environmental orthodoxy" or "far left's equivalent".
Or maybe there is also a "Newton and Galileo orthodoxy" and Aristotle was right all this time?
What the authors of the book were primarily guilty of was not questioning the scientific orthodoxy about the effects of global warming, but suggesting that carbon abatement was a costly way of addressing global warming compared to alternative remedies. In short, they arrived at the "wrong" political/economic conclusions, where wrong == unpopular.
What we need are large scale technological solutions.
There are processes that remove CO_2 from the atmosphere. Take photosynthesis as an example. Animals have exhaled CO_2 as long as they existed. We do not need to stop it.
(There may be a point that restricting the output to sensible levels is worthwhile. But the sensible level can be above zero.)
When we burn fossilized fuels, we're taking fossilized carbon and putting it into the atmosphere- billions of years worth of the natural process of fossilization reversed nearly instantaneously. In order for that to be compensated for naturally, we'd have to increase fossilization rates. This is impossible. Only a comparative technological solution to increasing fossilization rate (i.e. figuring out how to bury all that atmospheric carbon) will work.
http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/2009/10/sigh-last-post-on-supe...
These guys deserve what they're getting. They should have stuck to small scale sociology in areas no-one else was much familiar with.
That guy is advocating that the US, China and India should use military power to enforce pollution controls? That's insane.
He's not talking about military power alone. His argument is that consensus among the four major world powers would be able to accomplish carbon reductions. It's a reasonable point.
"I'll do my best to get your money through providing services, selling products, and ultimately armed robbery" is the same line of reasoning.
In which case, assuming you actually believe this, you would be contradicting yourself and agreeing with DeLong that it isn't totally futile to expect concerted action to achieve significant emissions reductions.
All that being said, there are many cases of international efforts reducing the emissions of environmentally damaging substances (i.e. acid rain, ozone depletion) without resort to armed conflict. So I don't think your position holds up to the scrutiny of the real world. It feels more like an ideological reaction to the existence of global warming (which no-one seriously disputes these days) than an attempt to think through the underlying issues.
But the first reply from the author's in the NYTimes article makes it clear: The real purpose of the chapter is figuring out how to cool the Earth if indeed it becomes catastrophically warmer. (That is the “global cooling” in our subtitle. If someone interprets our brief mention of the global-cooling scare of the 1970’s as an assertion of “a scientific consensus that the planet was cooling,” that feels like a willful misreading.)
That being said can anyone provide the text of the "brief mention"?
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/environment/article687...
These guys are trying to weasel out of having written what they've written by claiming the words they use don't mean what everyone else uses them to mean. Which is funny, because not knowing the language of your field is arguably a sign of worse ignorance than getting facts wrong in good faith after doing serious research.
These guys are pandering to the market for global denialism because that market buys books. Nothing wrong with that, but people who know their stuff are dead right to eviscerate them in the NYTimes because it's a bad faith pollution of the public discourse. So bring on the down-modding guys, I've got plenty to burn.