Hacker News Reader

Latin is not magical. While your idea is old enough to be mostly quaint and charming, the fact of the matter is that it's completely unrealistic. Not only that; it's already been tried, although using Sanskrit, not Latin. You've basically rediscovered a bad idea from the 80ies

View on HN

I suspect that a lot of the "Latin helps you with English" meme comes from the coming together of a couple of things:

1. Some schools wanting to teach Latin at least in part simply because it was part of a classical Western curriculum

but 2. Wanting to justify that inclusion based on more modern practical concerns than it just being something properly educated people learn.

Nothing against Latin or classical Western liberal arts. But the idea that Latin uniquely helps with English is sort of silly.

Personally Latin helped me with English mostly because my Latin classes were the only place I ever got any formal instruction in English grammar.

English might be German, French, etc. influenced, but it's nowhere as straightforward as German. Also, it is no surprise that it's about as difficult to learn as a foreign language as Xhosa.

Quidquid latine dictum, altum videtur.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com