And it's not "the only hope" - there will be more Android phones out, and the whole thing will only continue to improve.
And it's not "the only hope" - there will be more Android phones out, and the whole thing will only continue to improve.
If I make an iPhone app, then it'll work for every person with an iPhone and every person with an iPod touch. The same's not true for Android, which is why developers are reporting failures with the applications they're designing for it.
I've never used Android, unfortunately—can't find people with the phone to irritate/mug—but I'd imagine it's good, and I like that Google's released an OS with some focus on being good, because cell phone companies showed in the last decade that they don't give a damn about good when left to their own devices. Where I don't have faith in it, though, is in its attempt to make a developer haven that the iPhone doesn't offer. It seems that there're integral problems to its developer experience that won't fix themselves easily.
I shouldn't have to point out the level of build in the iPhone apps gallery. Those applications are gorgeous. Better than most PC apps, I'd argue, in their compactness and elegance. Developers have an edge on the iPhone because there's an established design standard, and there's an established screen size. So they can spend as long as they need fiddling to make their app perfect within those confines. On Android, that's not possible.
To use an unnecessary metaphor, iPhone apps are haiku and Android apps are open verse. On the one hand, it's nice not to have limits, but on the other, you find it's much easier to make something beautiful when you're given set restraints with which to riff on.
In a sense all software usage is just a series of tweaks. Otherwise you'd just have a big button to push and it would 'do stuff'. If that 'stuff' just happened to be exactly what you wanted then that would be fantastic. But that isn't reality. Reality is sometimes messy and complex so sometimes you need the ability to tweak things deal with the messy and complex problems from the real world.
Phones definitely fall into the sphere of things I like to hack on. That's definitely the crux of the difference of opinions. I would agree with you when talking about, say, cars, but a computing device that I physically own is something I want access to.
unalone, will you be at Startup School this Saturday? If so, you're welcome to borrow my Android Dev Phone for the day to play around with. I rotate between that phone, an iPhone, and a Nokia E75 depending on what I'm working on.
(back on topic) Considering the amount of attention that jwz gets, someone on the Android team should send him a free phone to tinker with asap.
Besides, in D companies, all tank names have to start with D. People being who they are, 95% were named "Death .*" I thought "a place of utter misery and wretchedness" would be pretty accurate for just about anybody participating in a battle, regardless of side. I never got any closer than training, and even that sucked quite badly.
I seriously wonder what will happen when Apple upgrades the screen resolution to 800x400 or attempts to fit in new functionality such as multitasking without altering the current applications' VMs.
Apple's not stupid. If they up the screen resolution, and I'm not so sure they will any time soon, they'll do it in a way that maintains aspect ratio and offer a way for older apps to adjust. As things stand right now, the resolution is brilliant. Not much reason yet to up it any further.
Plus, AAPL's "throw away and buy the shiny new one" ethos has kept the majority of users constantly updating their already new ipod/iphone/mac for quite some time, so this fragmentation might as well be yet another strong point on their evil marketing plot. "1st gen iphone? Sheesh, that's too old, go get a new one"
That you're stuck in their unjustifiably-oddball bytecode-interpreter sandbox (no JIT!) makes it particularly hard to just implement things yourself in 'userspace'.
People have been saying "there will be a glut of Android phones out in a few months" for well over a year. This is the first Android hardware that isn't obviously a pile of shit -- it's actually better than the iPhone in many ways! Now we get to see if the software can live up to it.
It's pretty evident if you think about it: they wanted something open source under a liberal license (Apache/BSD rather than GPL), and so did not want to touch Sun's Java implementation. Therefore, they did their own thing, which is a much solution than hassling with Sun about licensing. I suspect we'll see performance improvements with time; it's not as if Google doesn't have the resources to create a JIT if/when they want.