Personally I have a problem seeing much value in Yahoo except maybe Flickr and some other assets but maybe MS can use it to boost Bing or something
Personally I have a problem seeing much value in Yahoo except maybe Flickr and some other assets but maybe MS can use it to boost Bing or something
Edit: maxerickson pointed out my wrongness. YHOO will be much more expensive, but the 10x number was in error.
The market cap doesn't necessarily capture the takeover price, but I doubt it is wrong by 10 times.
That said, I hadn't realized MSFT offered so much before. I thought their last offer was when YHOO was still at 17, so I was incorrect.
I think a buyout price will be somewhere in the range of 80-100bln.
Let's not pretend like Yahoo is a $45B company. It is consistently valued between +/- $5B.
Buying Yahoo today for anything less than $65B would be cheaper than the previous offer.
I was agreeing with you, and my point was that Yahoo is today still an extremely cheap buyout target. Any argument that MM has increased the market value of the US operations (which is the part she actually runs) appears unfounded.
If you dumped the Alibaba and Yahoo Japan holdings, Yahoo would be doing $1.x billion per year in profit.
That $1.x billion would still be valued at a likely 15 to 25 times. Yahoo's core business is worth a lot closer to $20 billion, and under no scenario would it ever be valued at $5 billion.
The calculation you're using is backwards: it's the Alibaba & Yahoo Japan assets that are being discounted. Typically assets and cash are always discounted. It's earnings that matter the most, by far, when it comes to the valuation.
And that's trivially easy to prove: your argument rests on the claim that $1.x billion in earnings would be valued at 4x times. That would never happen.
Even if you were aggressive and pushed their net income down to $500 million on $4.5b in sales, you're talking about a 10 pe ratio. That also would not happen.
Even when things were at their absolute worst in the last ten years - pre Alibaba - Yahoo still carried an $11 to $15 billion valuation. And that's the absolute worst context post dotcom bubble crash.
The parent's position was that Yahoo's core is worth $5 billion. Well today AOL is worth $3.7 billion (with not much on their balance sheet of consequence). It's plainly obviously that under no scenario will Yahoo's business be valued at $5b when AOL is commanding a $3.7b valuation.