Hacker News Reader

Comment by gcb | Hacker News Reader

Probably what everyone said about python's indentation syntax.

I like both approaches. it's better then having useless {. In some cases improve readability over python lack of marks. and risking mod down by the audience we have here, it's (much (better then (the gratuitous use of (parenthesis in lisp)))))

View on HN

  how (
      is {
           this();
          }
      any();
      better(
               than[$parenthesis]
             );
      );

?

Why do people use full tabs and put the braces at the indentation level of the opening statement? I have discovered the one true coding style: 2 spaces indent, opening character immediately after opening statement, closing character on new line indented with preceding code block

    how (
      is {
        this();
        }
      any();
      better(
        than[$parenthesis]
        );
      );

A 2 space indent loses at 'visual overview' of larger (and more representative) expanses of code. A 4 space indent maintains clarity at the level of a skim or casual glance, even if it "fails" at the contrived (but simple) example shown here.

Supporting "larger" expanses of code is a pathological feature, not a benefit. If the code doesn't break back to the baseline after more than half a page, there's something wrong with that code in 99.9% of the cases.

Though true, a 2 space indent visually 'breaks' whenever there's (conservatively speaking) more than 8 lines of code on a single level followed by several further indented lines. After that, the indentation level of the immediately following less indented lines is not available to the average skimmer.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com