I've read the following arguments already, but with portions of them implicit. See if you can determine why the people are talking at cross points:
- "I generate VM server images for all my needs, and deploy to virtualization infrastructure behind load balancers to handle services. I treat he OS like an application like the rest of the stack, and all my data is abstracted to a data layer. I just generate a new image with patches and test it, then deploy if it works in my test suite."
- "I have hundreds of servers in dozens of roles with different software needs, and I need them to be secure and stable in a timely fashion, and I can't spend multiple weeks achieving that. Long term support and back-patching allows me the time to plan needed large changes in infrastructure without having to spend all my time managing updates, software changes and configuration changes multiple steps down the dependency graph."
- "I have a few servers with a few roles, or many servers with one or two roles, and I can manage frequent updates just fine, and it allows me to take advantage of the newest features, get security updates immediately as the software authors fix it, and I don't have to worry about end of life of software."
- "I have an application stack with multiple dependencies, and I just make sure to update my stack as I make changes to the software. I would love/have set up continuous integration software to build and test everything as I go, so I know if it works or not before taking it live."
As someone who's been in all of these situations at different points, often multiple at once, let me be clear: Unless you have an argument that addresses ALL of these situations, you really haven't thought through the issue.