But then consider situations where information is unreliable:
- Cheating because you can't trust others not to cheat, i.e. to protect yourself, and everyone ends up cheating, as in Prisoner's Dilemma.
- In a lot of situations, you may not even know who is cheating and by how much, but you might be sure someone is cheating. This will feed back into your own incentives to cheat. I believe OPEC suffers from this a lot.