Make Yourself Presentable
jasonsantamaria.com
jasonsantamaria.com
I agree with what he says about slide design, but I think practicing your talk is the most important thing. I always give extemporaneous talks. Practicing doesn't provide you with a verbatim script, but it does provide you with certain ready-made phrases you can pull from your mind, along with the intuition of "I just said X, I need to make sure I mention Y."
It's great practice for her. What surprises me is that even after seeing and appreciating this style of presentation several times the other kids persist with the old way.
If you're going to share the presentation, it's a decent idea to have a deck to present with and a deck to hand out later. If your presentation deck's a good read, that's what half your audience'll wind up doing instead of listening to you!
As for presenting itself, that's all about practice. I usually paraphrase my written speech each time I practice so that I stay involved in the content, vs. just reading it.
In fact, that technique just strikes me as a lazy way for professors to force students to pay attention to presentations that are apparently not otherwise interesting enough.
The slides aren't useless afterwards because the version put up afterwards may contain all the words.
Saying this is lazy is like saying that giving students problem sets without giving solutions simultaneously is lazy. It's the same principle - if you give out solutions, you are asking the students to not cheat by working backwards from the answer, to have 100% motivation to understand the problems on their own. No student is always that motivated all of the time in all of their coursework, but tricks like that will induce them to the extra effort.
Teaching has both "hard" techniques and "soft" ones. Using both will speed learning.