" It may well be that other organizations -- smaller firms and universities -- are making up the shortfall in investment in research. According to this interpretation, what is happening is a reallocation of research from large corporate labs to more efficient cient organizations."
The suggestion that universities might be more efficient than private corporations at anything is almost comic.
But this isn't an error. There is actually something quite profound at work. It is indeed the case that "smaller firms and universities" are more efficient at commercializing new technology than most large corporations. But it's not the smaller firms and universities independently; it's the smaller firms and universities together as one super-entity.
In Silicon Valley, the grad students quit and found a startup. Their advisor joins the Board. The university creates the IP. The startup commercializes it.
The puzzle for me ten years ago was this: Where is the licensing revenue for the universities? If they're creating the IP, then how come they're not getting anything back?
The answer is that they are, but in the form of alumni donations. :-D