Craigslist personals associated with 16 percent boost in HIV infections
arstechnica.com
arstechnica.com
There's startup potential there.
It might seem convenient to use that argument when it comes to defending something dear to us such as Craigslist. But when it comes to more sensitive social and economic issues I wish we would see the same skepticism.
I don't doubt the correlation but to pin this on craigslist specifically seems dubious at best.
> Conveniently, the spread of Craigslist provides a natural experiment: local sites were rolled out gradually over time, allowing the comparison of infection rates before and after their arrival...
> The data suggests that there was no rise in infection rate in advance of Craigslist opening shop, and there appears to be a bit of lag after a local site opens. This makes sense given that each city will take some time before users discover and start using the service, and the authors looked into this in more detail by tracking the number of ads present in each local site. Within a year of the opening of a local Craigslist, as activity picked up, HIV infections began to rise. The effect remained after the authors controlled for a variety of other demographic factors in each area.
So if the data says you can consistently expect a spike in infection rates a year after a local CL opens, and that effect is consistent across communities, it seems unlikely that other sites would be affecting that -- unless they were rolling out their own local sites in the same communities as CL was, at roughly the same time.
Of course the title makes it sound 23 times more severe.
Whether one is repulsed by the implications of a study has no effects on its truth value.
Should we stop doing statistics because it can never prove anything? Should we only accept that statistical results are valid when they are convenient and fit with our existing world view?