To some degree, yes. When you're talking about CSS skills, the distinction is somewhat blurred, because getting things to look right is a big part of front-end programming. Creating things that look bad reads as sloppiness. When you're working for a client and faithfully implementing the client's designs, this is particularly unfair, but it's still the case even then.

At any rate, the ability to make a rudimentary web page with HTML and CSS is not exactly impressive. I assume that's why jchendy said "… unless they're really impressive." Like, cool tech demos with HTML and CSS probably would help get you hired, but making a '90s-tastic resume is not even in the same neighborhood.

Yes, but the problem is you hit that no-mans-land between "I'm going to just format text in a readable way" and "I'm going to try to make this look nice", and missed both.

If you're going to start styling it (and in resumes, once background color enters into the picture, that's styling it), you really need to clean it up and make it look nice. Otherwise, going for a simple resume that's just text is probably going to serve you better.

I'd admittedly probably toss this resume as-is.

(Also, what about a DL for your experience rather than header/list?)