Six decades ago a critic attacked bland "subtopia" in British towns
bbc.com
bbc.com
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Betjeman#Betjeman_and_arch...
More interesting:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hotelling%27s_law
"principle of minimum differentiation"
The central building is typically the court house, surrounded by local businesses and variety of churches, maybe a jail. There is a vast variety of architectural style among the courthouses. Some historic, some not. Some even hosted old west gun fights [2].
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_Mile
The real high street is probably Princes Street, which is in the New Town, which is fairly old as well:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Princes_Street
While being a spectacular street to walk along - the actual shops are pretty dreary. Last time I checked there were 3 O2 mobile phone shops.... which seems a bit much for one street that isn't that long.
The Royal Mile is a bloody awful tartan covered tourist trap despite having some fantastic buildings.
My favourite part of Edinburgh is Leith and the shore area. I lived just off of the bottom of Leith walk and always loved dawdling across Leith Links to work in Great Michael house.
If you're in a non-Hotelling market, you win by doing something revolutionarily better than everyone else. In a Hotelling market, you win by perfect execution of a commodity.
I guess a dotcom analogy would be '07 smartphones were a non-Hotelling market when the iphone was introduced, and the android device market is clearly a Hotelling market where they're all about the same but the phone mfgr that screws up the least (hardware reliability, specs, bloatware, whatever) is the winner. The transition between those markets sometimes really trips up businesses and customers.