In general I think the problem is just laziness; the people running the project optimize it for themselves (active participants) rather than their users. It doesn't help that the most popular software (Mailman/Pipermail) is mediocre.
In general I think the problem is just laziness; the people running the project optimize it for themselves (active participants) rather than their users. It doesn't help that the most popular software (Mailman/Pipermail) is mediocre.
This is pretty reasonable, if you think about it: it's worth making life nice for the people donating hundreds or thousands of hours of their time to answer questions, as well as for the people who only plan to interact with the system for a couple of questions.
To the OP: Try the http://gmane.org/ NNTP/web mirrors of mailing lists, if you don't want to sign up for them. In particular, reading lists via NNTP from gmane in Thunderbird is pretty nice, with real threaded discussions going back as far as you want, and no need to sign up, etc. (screenshot: http://hcs.harvard.edu/~jrus/TextMate/gmane-thunderbird.png)
I really think the main problem is not the concept of mailing lists (and email/nntp) generally, but instead, as you suggest, the software that runs it. Google groups/mailman/etc. are all IMO pretty crappy from both maintainer and user perspectives, but they work well enough that no one's really putting effort into better mailing list software. Likewise, most mail clients are pretty crappy –either unconfigurable or with a difficult learning curve for configuration, with insufficiently easy-to-set-up and insufficiently flexible rule systems, etc. – when you get down to it. I should be able to absolutely instantly (<10 seconds) set up my email client to filter for only replies to my topics or mentions of my name in a particular mailing list (for example), but currently this is an involved process in every mail client I've ever used.
Of course, email is so so so much better for extended technical discussions than any web forum I've seen, that we all stick with it despite its flaws.
Making email better is undervalued. Love to see startups help extend it.
You got me on the money equation. But I'm sure there's some way to make it.
Unless your users are actually contributing money or time (most won't), I'd call that smart, not lazy.
But yes, you can just send your email to (for example) python-list@python.org and then when people do a reply-to-all it will reply to you and the list... But what about a list-reply? (Gmail automatically replies to the list, not the sender) Does the mailing list software also forward mail from your thread to you, even if you're not subscribed?
Sounds like a business opportunity.
It was a while back, http://alicious.com/2008/best-online-mailing-list-management... , and I never really finished the public write up but put it online anyway ... isn't this the space that Google Wave is supposed to be filling now.