The problem in the states is very very different. In the states you have three corporations providing shit, slow service. Th
Traffic shaping, which stops one person on a contented link (ie ADSL) ruining everyone else's day by torrenting every last drop of bandwidth. Its been a fact of life for many years.
THe problem in the states can be characterised in two ways:
* A lack of competition
There is often only one ISP in town, and they don't have to try hard. This means that service is terrible, and so is innovation.
* A lack of bandwidth
In Europe bandwidth exchanges, or peering exchanges are normally run by a cooperative. This means that its in everyone's interest to talk to everyone else as fast as possible. Its really really cheap to peer in london, (http://www.lonap.net/fees.shtml)
In the states, exchanges are run by either AT&T, verizon or level3. Which means everything costs squillions. As there is no need to provide more bandwidth, because customers can't move between ISPs so no one peers.
For example in the EU, ISPs are more than keen to have CDN leaf nodes in their infrastructure, it lowers costs and improves customer experiences. However they can't charge Netflix et al to install them because there is too much competition.
Its not like they can limit access to netflix for a few months to make a point, because their customers would change ISPs. Something not possible in the States.
So net neutrality is really a side issue to competition.