My hunch is, it is crucial to keep developers and avoid situations where you have to maintain other peoples code as much as possible.
Just a quick idea, as I was writing this:
Lets compare software with fiction: assume, an author has written a quick draft for a story. It works great, it has more potential, some parts still don't fit in. Would you honestly take the story away from the author and give it to a handful of others to finish it and turn it into a bestseller? It is likely, that you get a mix of styles that gets worse and worse, the more people touch it.
Sounds familiar?