I took that as the point of the piece -- that there is no moral consensus. That even unalienable truths like, "All men are created equal" are being labelled as opinions and lumped in the same category as one's favorite color or sports team.
I took that as the point of the piece -- that there is no moral consensus. That even unalienable truths like, "All men are created equal" are being labelled as opinions and lumped in the same category as one's favorite color or sports team.
I would agree with the author that children shouldn't be only taught relativism, but I hope we can forgive a lack of nuance in 2nd-grade curricula. Having wiggle room and nuance in these conversations is part of how civilization has progressed, and that's stifled by the idea that all morality is derived from some semi-knowable perfect absolute reality.
> Given the presence of moral relativism in some academic circles, some people might naturally assume that philosophers themselves are to blame.
and then a link to this:
http://www.thenewamerican.com/culture/education/item/372-mor...
I generally don't go for guilt by association, but can't believe he linked to this nonsense as some sort of support for his position.
"All men are created equal" is a moral consensus or opinion to me. Some are definitely more equal than others.
Unalienable rights can be abused, but not taken away. If someone is murdered by a dictator for his opinions, that is wrong regardless of the legality of the action, the power imbalance in play, or the "personal morality" of the dictator. That is, the human right to life was violated.
> I'd argue that "all men are created equal" is NOT an absolute moral truth... There are plenty of people who consider themselves to be moral people who don't feel that way.
The 'absolute' isn't about unanimity. It's about truth regardless of disagreement. That's the way truth works. Some people think humans never visited the Moon. And they're wrong. As were the Boston bombers, as was Ariel Castro, as was Bernie Madoff.