Silicon Valley to millennials: Drop dead
edition.cnn.com
edition.cnn.com
Seems like a rant piece.
Whether he's right or not, your point seems to miss the mark.
I'm personally vulnerable to this line of thinking, but I can definitely see that silicon valley is getting rich but expecting everyone else to chip in to solve the problem and advocating a solution that is a nonstarter in most circles.
I think that, at the very least, Piketty is right and we need a progressive tax on capital gains.
I would simply envisage less popular resistance to a real progressive tax on capital gains than to a basic income (see: welfare fraud), but maybe I'm wrong.
I don't have a particularly great solution to our problem, but I do think there are meaningful steps we can take between an ideal world and the real one that are better than nothing. Silicon valley should surely start paying people closer to the value they provide.
What does this mean in concrete terms? We have a real (= non-imaginary, actual, existing) progressive tax on capital gains now. It's also at favorable rates (across the whole spectrum of its progressivity) compared to "regular" income, and especially favored compared to labor income (which pays payroll taxes, which are flat to regressive, on top of income taxes, which are progressive).
In fact, because of payroll taxes, its arguable that we have more "real progressive taxation" of capital gains than of labor income.