1912 Eighth Grade Examination for Bullitt County Schools
bullittcountyhistory.com
bullittcountyhistory.com
I can recall, in the 7th grade, struggling for a couple nights to be able to identify all of the european and Mediterranean countries for an exam. It took a couple hard nights of cramming, but by the time the exam came along, it was a walk in the park.
But ask me today to place Slovenia, Bulgaria, and Albania on a map - and I'd be at a loss.
Whereas the 1912 version only required basic arithmetic and trigonometry, the 2015 version requires, additionally: rational numbers, exponents and radicals, systems of linear equations, and basic statistics.
I just tried this myself and (barely) got them all right. Had to guess between NH and VT, and was somewhat shaky around AK, MS, and AL.
CN -> CT, PE -> PA, IW -> IA, MO -> MT (and I even had "MO" on Missouri)
Mississippi has the Mississippi River, and thus borders Louisiana.
The downside, besides having a horrible time remembering some chemical formula, or the year of the French revolution, is that I also cannot use a formula correctly unless I know how it is derived. I must walk every step of the proof before I can use any part of the formula, otherwise my brain simply refuses to see it correctly.
Interestingly enough, I am blessed with very good memory for situations and associations. I can tell you exactly how many olives were in the martini I ordered in July 2008 (3), or quote lines from my favorite shows at every occasion. I just can't remember what my brain seems classify as "generally useless facts".
As a graduate of the public schools in that county, I can't say that I received the same rigorous education that the test here indicates was once the standard. It's very strange to me to see this pop up now and then on the internet as an example of "look at the standards we once held our children to".
"We believe that in the passage of time the neglect of these books in the twentieth century will be regarded as an aberration, and not, as it is sometimes called today, a sign of progress. We think that progress, and progress in education in particular, depends on the incorporation of the ideas and images included in this set in the daily lives of all of us, from childhood through old age. In this view the disappearance of great books from education and from the reading of adults constitutes a calamity. In this view education in the West has been steadily deteriorating; the rising generation has been deprived of its birthright; the mess of pottage it has received in exchange has not been nutritious; adults have come to lead lives comparatively rich in material comforts and very poor in moral, intellectual, and spiritual tone."
-- Preface to "Great Books of the Western World", "The Great Conversation Vol. 1" (1951)
http://archive.org/stream/greatconversatio030336mbp/greatcon...
-- Me
(I take this stance because just the other day I watched an old Simpsons episode where Martin was made fun of by the substitute teacher for "bothering" to learn the historical significance of the Monroe Doctrine, and I was ashamed that any teacher, fictional or not, would behave in such a way)
Say all you want about the overuse of memorization in public education: I bet those 8th graders that could pass this test without looking half the answers up on Wikipedia had a more well-rounded education than most of us today.
And the attitude that, "Well why bother to learn history when I have wikipedia?" is the same attitude that causes people to become totally useless when their computer goes down and is no longer telling them what to do. I've had cashiers that literally could not make change when they didn't have a computer in front of them to do the subtraction.
It is similar to learning the why of multiplication rather than memorizing multiplication tables. If who know the why, you have a foundation laid for higher math. If you just memorize the results you lack the foundation. You sure can spit out results fast, but a computer can spit them out faster.
Same with dates and names for historical events. If you know what year the doctrine was issued, and who wrote it, there isn’t much knowledge that can be built on that. But if you understand the significance, but have no idea what year it was written or who wrote it, you can apply that knowledge to other situations.
Answer without knowing any dates.
And as far as "knowing the why" of multiplication being sufficient to lay the foundation of higher math, just try to solve a system of three simultaneous equations or find a volume with double integration on a classroom test, each problem requiring that a couple of dozen little algebraic operations be done correctly or the problem gets all messed up, when you really never learned what 7x5 or 8x(-3) are, but you fully understand what these operations mean. You'll pick a humanities major when you get to college and heave a great sigh of relief when you take your last "higher math" class.
I doubt you know (remember) the date of everything that happened in history. I do not doubt that you can reason about, understand, and learn from history.
No one is arguing for no memorization, ever. We are arguing against rote memorization and for learning how to think and reason. It is not a dichotomy, it's a continuum. Of course any example that someone comes up with by way of illustrating their position is going to have a quibble or counter. But that is kind of missing the forest for the trees, IMO.
To expand that line of thought. We have new tools now, like google, and an ever increasing body of facts. It was perhaps reasonable to 'memorize the world' in 1912; there is no chance of it today. A few dozen European, white dead authors to read, handfuls of major population centers, tons of jobs related to shipping corn and such (thank you ships and trains!), and so memorizing the almanac and learning percentages made a lot of sense (perhaps, I'll stipulate it). Now, to have an effective mind you have to be able to find and assimilate data from several sources quickly, and find the meaning behind the facts. I don't know the answer to your Monroe Doctrine question, but I have no doubt that I could get you the answer quickly, and write an "A", graduate level paper in a few days should I choose. That's what I need to succeed in this world, not know the stupid date of some treaty.
Funny now, I learned more after watching The Tudors, Wolf Hall, and The White Queen, than I did it that awful class. Wasn't all bad though. We got to make our own Medieval weapons (I made a Morning Star) and had a tour book of the London Dungeon (pretty gruesome) hanging on the classroom wall; won't find that these days.