http://gawker.com/5811371/heres-the-cheesy-anti-union-video-...
http://gawker.com/behold-targets-brand-new-cheesy-anti-union...
http://gawker.com/5811371/heres-the-cheesy-anti-union-video-...
http://gawker.com/behold-targets-brand-new-cheesy-anti-union...
So, to this day, I loathe unions, in practice, perhaps not in theory, but in practice I do. I also did not enjoy the 'machismo' that happens in unions.
[1] I sprained my ankle at work while doing work and yet they did nothing for me. I had to pay the xray bills myself (I don't recall how much it was, but they did nothing to make things better for me). So I have little sympathy for the institution.
So yeah. My union good, your union bad, let's not make blanket assertions based on one experience...
Just so I have this straight, you thought that a good outcome was to have your (clearly abusive) manager(s) silently seething with rage against you, but impotent to act on it, because of the union protection?
This was a good outcome to you, over, say leaving that hostile environment as fast as humanly possible, or, I don't know, turning in the manager(s) to higher-ups (or to state agencies if the abuse warranted)?
Why should the burden be on the worker to find a new job anyway? If the abuse is coming from mgmt, it should be their responsibility to make it right.
Do you think that leaving the abusive manager in place, but impotent, is a better outcome? For whom? The company, the employees?
It's a better outcome for the employees. They have more leverage over their managers and are protected from abuse. If the manager is seething and impotent over his inability to mistreat his employees, maybe he can do what others have suggested the employee do and find another job.
The entire management structure in place was the problem. Are you seriously suggesting I should have attempted to contact my manager's boss in the USA, instead of joining a union?
Without a union, his likely outcomes were to leave his job, possibly winding up at another abusive organization that experienced no penalties for abusive behaviour, or report his manager to higher-ups (who may have been aware or complicit in the abuse) and suffer retaliation when his manager found out, or report his organization to authorities and likely suffer retaliation from the organization as a whole. None of these are particularly positive outcomes, which is a direct result of a large organization having more power than an individual, unorganized worker.
Yes. I had entered that job from a social welfare benefit, and if I were fired or forced to leave the job, I would be subject to a 13 week stand-down.
> This was a good outcome to you, over, say leaving that hostile environment as fast as humanly possible, or, I don't know, turning in the manager(s) to higher-ups (or to state agencies if the abuse warranted)?
My recourses would have required legal action to the Employment Court, and when you're earning minimum wage, lawyers aren't easy to come by.
So yes, it was good that I could keep earning the money I needed to live, until I found a better job.