College Enrollment Hits All-Time High, Fueled by Community College Surge
pewresearch.org
pewresearch.org
Recession is bad for many, but lines the pockets of others.
Conversely, there are people who lose money or aren't making as much money when the economy is doing well (for an in-your-face example, Walmart)
On another note, it does not necessary make me smile to see enrollment is increasing. I feel institutional learning has hurt a lot of the ingenuity and creativity in the U.S. and many don't take away the true value of post-secondary learning because they feel they have to go to college or will be left out.
The other side, it does make me smile because it is less competition for me when so many get wrapped up in an additional four years of education. -- My sentiments here by the way are supported by the evolution of education in our country. How so? It is accepted fact that the reason we made secondary school (high school) mandatory in the United States was to help us get out of the great depression and high unemployment by causing less competition in the work force for adults. When high school became mandatory it caused a lot of outrage, especially in the blue-collar communities where after 8th grade children would go to work and begin careers to help support their families.
I could go on, but there is some interesting food for thought.
1. Factory Burns Down -- Lost wealth 2. Factory no longer competitive - Lost Wealth 3. Built too many houses/widgets/etc - Lost Wealth
You lose wealth when jobs that a skilled worker had disappear, not because of technology but because it's not needed anymore. Say for instance you trained 1000 people to run a specialized machine that was used to mine gold in a certain region. As soon as that gold runs out all the investments made in that specific region that are not transferable are lost.
All three of your examples are wrong in fact. In every case someone else is going to make money.
1. "Factory burns down -- lost wealth" -- Well a competing factory will pick up that business, sorry. Not to mention if the factory wants to rebuild, construction workers make money.
2. "Factory no longer competitive - lost wealth" Again, no. If a factory is no longer competitive, a competitor will take that business.
3. "Built too many houses/widgets/etc - lost wealth" Lastly, again, no. Let's look at the housing market which was your first mention. People are losing their houses right? Then there are people that buy those houses at huge discounts from Sheriff's sale, fix it up, resell it later for profit.
And for the paragraph at the bottom of your comment, wrong again. As soon as the gold runs out in that region, a company in another region with gold will be picking up that loss of business and making money.
Thanks for the debate though.
1. Even if a competing company picks up that business wealth is still lost; Sure the other company may earn more money but the total wealth in the world has gone down. That other company could've productively produced some other good, and now has to produce what the other did. Also, the construction workers rebuilding it is just bastiat's broken window fallacy (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parable_of_the_broken_window). If the factory didn't burn down the construction workers could have built new things, not merely replacing old.
2.I may have not stated this one clearly enough; when a factory looses it's competitive edge due to mismanagement it's losing wealth. If they were able to properly manage the company everyone would be richer on average.
3. When you build too much of a good that isn't needed then you've lost wealth overall. The housing example might be too complicated, it has a lot of interrelated factors, but lets assume I make action figures. If I produce 100 Billion of them and there are only 1 million people that want them -- we've lost wealth... The time and energy producing the extra ones has now been squandered. Sure the market may expand to 10 million people with deep discounts but wealth was still lost.
Let me explain, first I don't think pop is the right word, stock bubbles pop, real-estate bubbles deflate much more slowly and this will take a looooong time.
Also, I do not believe there is a higher education bubble in the "you don't need college" sense. I believe there is a bubble in how much many colleges are charging for a 4 year degree.
And I think that as lower tier schools gain respectability, this will create downward price pressure.
Obviously some places will remain ridiculously expensive and exclusive, because that is the very point of their existence. But hopefully future generations will be able to get a respectable degree without having to literally mortgage their future.
It appears that in the midst of the recession, the government has made it more expensive to bring in international students (one quote I got was "one international MASc student is similar to one local post-doctoral student") on a year-by-year expense, since our engineering graduate programs are research based and are thus funded. This was meant as an attempt to provide local new-grads with more opportunities in a dire job market, and in that sense, it certainly worked
Shouldn't the question be, "Will going to college make one happy?" That Starbucks barista with a B.A. in Polynesian languages might actually be happier than the hotshot programmer at the startup of the month.