Perhaps that sort of logic is rolled into the rate distortion metrics of Daala? But if so, I suspect this bug would not be.
Perhaps that sort of logic is rolled into the rate distortion metrics of Daala? But if so, I suspect this bug would not be.
The better approach, I think, is some form of "temporal RDO", where you spend more bits on places that will be good predictors of future frames. We discussed the idea in a Theora update in 2010 [0]. x264 implemented it even before then (under the name "mbtree" [1]). It is not yet implemented in Daala, as we do not have two-pass rate control or lookahead yet. It's possible to do one-pass, no-lookahead versions by estimating future prediction efficiency based on the past, but you want one with full lookahead to compare against to make sure those estimates are doing the right thing.
I am not sure temporal RDO would save us here, because the issues described only occur in areas of the frame that are being updated. It still might have, in this case---these things are relative---but we could construct cases where it would fail to do so.
[0] https://people.xiph.org/~xiphmont/demo/theora/demo9.html
[1] http://www.x264.nl/developers/Dark_Shikari/MBtree%20paper.pd...