Is your reasoning that of an experienced, competent cryptographer? Because mine isn't. I'm not a cryptographer's peer, either, and I'll bet you aren't either. Step one--nobody said step all, but step one--is establishing your bona fides to determine whether it is worth burning cycles on your idea, because proving or disproving cryptography is very hard and very time-consuming. It is a heuristic that, generally speaking, works pretty well.