Ask HN: Anyone moved away from GitHub to Phabricator? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Anyone moved away from GitHub to Phabricator?

4 pointsravenkat3 comments

I'd like to know the experience of engineers who moved away from github to phabricator. Phabricator is really good but it has no third party app support like github. We use circle CI to run all the tests after send a pull request in github. I couldn't find a support for CI in phabricator.

View on HN

I've been trying to. But one big roadblock is the need for all the call signs in Phabricator.

Some of our core work is now on Phabricator, but there are a number of sharp edges to cut yourself on when you make the switch and this holds back the wholesale switch from using Phabricator as a "Project Mangement, Bug Tracker, Wiki, etc, tool", to using it as "Source Code Hosting + Project Management + Bug Tracker, Wiki, etc." and getting all the extra integration benefits for our repos.

Most of these have future answers in the form of work currently on the drawing board by the devs. Waiting for the PEBKAC aka Nuance tools drives me nuts. They are great devs, but sometimes the slow pace of progress on some things hurts. CI tooling via Drydock & Harbourmaster has been in progress for at least 2 years now, Nuance has been in the wiki ahead of proper project creation for quite some time now too.

Really hope that the Launch of Phacility brings them the resources to speed up development.

We didn't move away (never were using GitHub), but we've done our CI hooks from inside arc (the command line client for phabricator) and it's worked pretty well (it means you need to be able to reach both phabricator and our CI server, but since phabricator is self-hosted that's not really a problem). A little manual, but pretty straightforward to get setup.

Overall, we greatly prefer phabricator's review tools (batch email notifications) + general git workflow (linear history on master) so haven't really looked into GitHub enterprise.

We use both Phabricator and Github together -- it was super easy to set up. I think Phabricator has a CI tool on their roadmap. They also have an API, but it's a bit of a clusterfuck, which may help explain the dearth of integrations.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com