Articles like this are interesting, but a little sickening in that they assume that continually increasing defense spending is actually a good idea.
I'd work for Swoopo long before I would work for a defense startup.
Articles like this are interesting, but a little sickening in that they assume that continually increasing defense spending is actually a good idea.
I'd work for Swoopo long before I would work for a defense startup.
Do you honestly believe that? I don't see how it's even possible unless we sedate everyone in some kind of matrix like false utopian state. It's good to dream though.
If peak oil is true, I would predict quite the opposite.
I really doubt that. (Well, as long as we limit ourselves to times when there were Homo Sapiens in Europe.)
Also, see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democratic_peace_theory
Name one.
Once (if) that goes away, Western Europe will either have to pony up for it's own defense, or be held hostage to outside powers with their own agendas (like Russia blackmailing Europe with gas supplies)
I don't see the struggle between national interests going anyway anytime unless and until the nation-state itself is rendered obsolete. People need stuff, and that creates conflict. Different groups of people will need different stuff. And let's not forget ideological problems -- Western Europe isn't exactly a model of social integration.
It only takes one bad actor to make all participants gear up for the potential to use force, and we've found that once geared up, the actual use of force is not far behind.
It's a prisoner's dilemma played out on a global stage. But you'd find the same situation with three thousand guys living in caves somewhere. War is a natural consequence of groups of unique and intelligent humans.
So your nation can be so inept as to not be able to control things inside it's borders (many nations fit this bill). If armed camps build up inside them and attack other countries, guess what? You're at war -- or something so close to war as to be indistinguishable from it.
If you'd like the world to work like some super-big version of your local country, where most conflicts are solved by some civil system, then you're going to have to have popular choice of representatives, mixed local, national, and world control, an independent court system built on something besides treaties, etc. The UN is nowhere near any of that.
There is the theory that democracies only compete via commerce. If you buy into that, then perhaps a world full of democracies would be the most peaceful. But I don't see that happening either any time soon.
It's just a long-shot. A real long-shot. I'd argue that in order to do away with war you would have to do away with 99.999% of the impetus for using violence under any circumstances. It'd be a world of extreme pacifists. Would that be such a great thing? Doesn't chaos -- whether war, sickness, disasters, etc -- contribute to evolution and growth? Do we really want to live in stasis? Or -- to put it in religious terms -- is heaven really such a great thing?
In any case, it is one thing to have stability in an affluent, post-religion area like Western Europe, quite another to have it worldwide. Many nations in the Mid East, for example, are comparable to medieval Europe - except that if the current regimes fall (as they might well, if oil loses its value) their subjects are more likely to create a Muslim Brotherhood-type regime than a liberal republic.
http://www.ted.com/talks/lang/eng/steven_pinker_on_the_myth_...
World peace could arise as the result of some extremely democratic/libertarian/scientific worldwide monoculture that agreed on everything but what they were willing to settle with words. I think that an unlikely end to the story, though. The easiest road to world peace is for someone to win. And that's not a happy ending in my book. I'll take war over that. It's nasty, but nowhere near as bad as tyranny.
Put another way, there will be war as long as there is crime. I hope that's forever. Living in a society that had actually done what it takes to eliminate crime completely would not be worth it to me. I feel the same way about a world without war.
1) Falkland's war between Argentina and Great Britain in 1982. 2) Greco-Turkish war in Cypress. 3) Indian-Pakistani wars (although this example is stretching it, as US influence in India is quite low) 4) The First and Second Cod War 5) The Turbot War
I can see the courageous absolutism of Gandhi working well on a small scale inspiring others to rebel against the status quo - but against a nation bent on destruction of your own people, say, what then.
What I find intriguing is that in a situation of combat between computer-piloted UAV it is purely technological advance that gives the advantage. That then is dissociating war from direct violence and making technology the battleground rather than military aggression and effective killing.
Sadly I don't believe, for now, that we can end human warring in favour of "robot wars".
You can't extrapolate from Gandhi to a generalized theory of resistance. His strategy worked well against the British Empire at a time that it had already decided that empires were more trouble than they're worth, and besides, we only came here to play cricket anyway. Any other imperial power would simply have shot him.
That's what I said. Worked small scale but won't work large scale = can't extrapolate. Did I miss something?
Policing will probably always be needed, but that is different. The police are not at war with criminals.