House passes health care reform bill
cnn.com
cnn.com
Here is a link to the bill: http://docs.house.gov/rules/health/111_ahcaa.pdf
Key question: So you and two other guys just got $15K in seed funding for your startup for the next three months.
Do you have to use that to buy health insurance or face a fine?
Does this scenario sound familiar to anyone?
First, you can look at the bill text on OpenCongress right here:
http://www.opencongress.org/bill/111-h3962/text
You'll find that it does not require "you and two guys who just got $15k in seed funding" to purchase company health insurance. Employers with payrolls in excess of $500,000/yr are required to cover their employees. Most responsible companies with payrolls like that already do.In fact, the bill does two things to make it easier for small businesses to handle health insurance:
* It provides grants to small business to provide health insurance, based on a dollar formula per qualified employee
* It allows companies with fewer than 25 employees to participate in the public health care exchange.
These are all just details, though, because the big picture issue here is that this is extremely good news for startups.
The fact that health insurance is tied to employers is a major challenge for the kinds of companies people on Hacker News try to start. For the first year or so of our company, we didn't offer health benefits, and that cost us candidates. Plenty of A-players need to cover families, and can't do it on the individual market. To understand how severe this problem is, work from the assumption that you simply cannot buy individual insurance at any reasonable rate.
The current system distorts both the health care market and the job market, and makes it harder both to start and grow new companies.
Your answer addresses this from the established startup side. My question is about people who are either not in business or who have just signed papers of incorporation. Perhaps they are just working under a memorandum of understanding. As I understand it, these folks are responsible for their own health insurance and are required to purchase it assuming they are able. If an Angel provides them with 100K for business development does that count as income? Do they then have to purchase insurance for themselves? For those guys, supposedly concentrating on finding a market and servicing it, are you saying there is a grant application process? Some forms to fill out? What, if anything, do they need to do that they are not doing now? Because there's obviously going to be something new for them to do, or they wouldn't have health care at all, right?
I think it's a safe approximation of the bill on the table that the founders of your hypothetical startup would need to have health insurance.
But they need health insurance now, for the same reason that they need to incorporate (eek! more big government regs!) before they start accepting money: because otherwise, there's a large number of plausible misfortunes that could bankrupt them personally. Have your appendix burst, or get hit by a car. No insurance? BK.
Your hypothetical founders make fuck-all in their first year anyways, and so it's likely they could pay whatever nominal fine the plan ends up with, which would be cheaper than insurance.
But that's a false economy. Because of the market distortions created by the health insurance companies, pharma, and hospitals, all of which set prices in collusion with the HR teams at big companies, you need insurance to have any meaningful access to health care in this country.
They would have to do something. Either you don't know what or can't explain it in a way that I got it. At one point they have grants. At another it's all just the same as now. Nothing to see here, please move along.
If you get a better answer I'd like to hear it. Because I'm thinking that insurance requirements for sole-dual founders will occur before expenses, especially due to their independent nature. You give me 50K and I'm broke, guess what? I'm not broke any more. Suddenly I can afford health insurance and don't need special help. That's all fine and dandy, but it means initial funding will need to be a little higher, that's all.
I don't know what the $50k you're talking about has to do with anything. As you know, people don't get $50k investments; corporations do. An ownership stake in an S-Corp that takes in $50k doesn't mean you have $50k in income, or even $25k. Talk to your accountant if you need help with the K-1 details here.
The idea that you'd have to spend that $50k on health insurance before servers is nonsensical. Companies with less than $500,000 in payroll aren't required to do anything vis a vis health insurance. The $50k is sitting in the ING account of an S-Corp. In a pre-revenue, pre-cash-flow-positive startup, it has nothing to do with your individual income until the S-Corp does a distribution.
I'm being maximally generous to your argument here, because the reality is that three ramen-eating startup founders would owe a negligible amount of fines for simply not buying insurance under this scheme.
So if me and 2 other guys want to drop out of the corporate world for a couple of years to give our startup a shot, be prepared to pay fines as part of the burn rate. Yet this is a benefit to us because even though it doesn't make economic sense for young people to buy health insurance, if something did go wrong we wouldn't have so much to worry about.
Got it.
(2) If 2.5% kills your company, you're screwed anyways.
(3) But that doesn't matter, because you and your 2 other guys are screwed anyways: if you get hit by a car and wind up in an ambulance, you BK.
I don't find this a compelling, or even interesting argument. Also, it's entirely hypothetical. An entirely hypothetical argument about a 2.5% tax increase for the uninsured.
However, based on actual experience, which I gather you lack (you're part of the corporate world, right?), I can tell you that the screwed up private health insurance system definitely keeps A-player talent locked up in the corporate world.
Either way, the argument you originally tried to put forward, which is that this bill would require you to pay for insurance before business expenses, is simply wrong. I'm sorry if I'm misreading you, but you appear not to understand how corporate cash flows work.
So yes, it's a big deal. I'm already screwed if I get hit by a car.
According to you, if I pull $20K out of my S-Corp for family expenses I'm paying more for health insurance I didn't want. If I leave the money in over the first of the year it's income and I'm paying more. If I form a new corp just for purposes of the startup I'm paying more.
I'm paying more. I'm not saying it's the end of the world. Obviously smarter people than me have decided that I need to pay more. So I'm paying more.
What I'm stuck on now is: Daniel, you're clearly over 35. Are you telling us you're not insured? Or did I misread you?
It would be easier to discuss this with you if you had
(a) read the bill,
(b) grokked basic corp accounting, and
(c) would explain where your numbers from.
From this discussion, to be totally frank, I think you have bigger problems with your impending startup than health insurance. Who distros $20k of a $50k investment out to a founder?