Only people with complaints or axes to grind tend to post in forums. So if you're just reading forums, you'd think that Comcast was the spawn of Satan. I've had Comcast in the Bay Area for the last 5 years. No problems at all to report. Their prices are outrageous, of course, but the product has been good.
* Internet service has been rock solid, never a problem
* Runs at close to advertised speeds
* Comcast adopted native IPv6 before other ISPs even knew what it was
* TV service has been probably ~99% reliable
Only complaint: When TV service went down once or twice, their phone support ability was utterly incompetent.
Basically, as long as you never have to interact with them in any way, Comcast is great.