Watermelon......... 8.2 cal/gal
Almond............. 7.0
Head of broccoli... 5.9
Cantaloupe......... 3.7
Corn cob........... 1.5
Beef............... 0.2
Source: USDA Watermelon......... 8.2 cal/gal
Almond............. 7.0
Head of broccoli... 5.9
Cantaloupe......... 3.7
Corn cob........... 1.5
Beef............... 0.2
Source: USDAWater consumption for everything but beef taken from here: http://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-gleason-almond-fa...
But it's the number for beef that is contentious. That's the whole point of your comment. And, unlike the others, it wasn't included when you made this comment last time.
FWIW: the same exercise comes up with a comparably terrible efficiency rating for rice.
Fattiest beef I could find (70/30 ground) is 1501cal/lb http://ndb.nal.usda.gov/ndb/foods/show/3960?man=&lfacet=&cou...
Using 4000gal/lb, this gives us a range for beef of 0.13-0.38cal/gal. To get to 1.0 you'd have to be using pure tallow
(Beef is indisputably inefficient, of course).
Slightly later
I'm finding it pretty difficult to come up with a credible number for (say) pork. It's easy to find estimates of gallons/lb of pork, but the kcal of different preparations of meat vary wildly, and the gallons/lb may represent all those different cuts (so you'd need % breakdown of all the parts/kcal per animal), or worse, the gal/lb numbers could just based on some representative cut from the animal.
Did a quick google search, and if the cow produced 2500gal of milk per year for 5 years before becoming meat, and the cow produced about 400lb of meat, then you end up with 1lb of beef + 30 gallons of milk for the amount of water the article states.
The livestock industry does its best to use everything.
Once the dairy cow has finished being a dairy cow they're sold off as low grade meat.
Are you using waterfootprint.org's "ground nuts in shell" as a proxy for almonds?
Source: California Department of Water Resources http://www.water.ca.gov/landwateruse/anaglwu.cfm
Further, per the same source, over twice as much water is applied to each acre of almonds and pistachios as each acre of melons, squash, and cucumbers.
What I've found so far for beef statistics doesn't make a lot of sense to me. For instance, California has the 4th largest cattle population in the U.S. (half of Texas' beef population), but is not in the top 10 beef producers. California is the top dairy producer, but it appears that only ~34% of the cattle population is dairy cattle. Further, it appears that chicken has been the meat of choice for the U.S. since the late 1990s.
Source: National Cattlemen's Beef Association: http://www.beefusa.org/CMDocs/BeefUSA/Producer%20Ed/Directio...