There is nothing that I fear more than loosing my photos, my visual biography.
That is why I am super conservative when it comes to software that wants to handle my photos.
What are the requirements for software that I allow to manage my photos:
- Very good chance of still being in the market in 5-10 years. This basically rules out all Google (Picasa), Apple (iPhoto, Aperture, Photos) products.
- Possibility to backup my photos on various destinations (not only one commercial cloud)
- A library format that is readable from external applications (SQL, metadata files)
- Good tools to search, compare and sort my library
- At least support two major platforms natively
Unfortunately, the only software that meets most of these requirements is Adobe's Lightroom. And this is very sad:
- It has too many features that I do not need - I am not a professional photographer
- It does not care about native UIs and its usability I still find weak
- It asks for a premium price for professional photographers (both the one-time fee and the creative cloud version)
How about alternatives?
- Aperture was a very good alternative, despite being only available for Mac
- I was disappointed by all open source alternatives; most of which are not easily available for Mac and Windows (Lightzone, Darkroom, Digikam, Shotwell)
- Digikam comes closest, but as it's KDE based, installation and native support on Windows and Mac is still weak
- Capture One Pro 8 works on Mac and Windows but is even more expensive than Lightroom and hence not worth it
- I do not know about any other photo management tool that is stable, multi platform and meets most of the conservative demands