Why is that undefined? Seems like it should obviously cause a fault...
class Example {
public:
static bool do_it;
virtual void do_it_if() {
if (g_do_it) return;
/* otherwise do something that dereferences this... */
}
};
void test1() {
Example::do_it = false;
static_cast<Example *>(NULL)->do_it_if();
}
void test2() {
Example::do_it = true;
static_cast<Example *>(NULL)->do_it_if();
}
In the above code, only test2 crashes (clang 6.0). If crashing was defined behavior you would need an extra check in the code generated for do_it_if.EDIT:
Also, it's worth explaining why test1 works even though do_it_if is virtual. Since there aren't any methods that override do_it_if, the virtual method lookup can be elided and you don't have to dereference this to find the vtable. If do_it_if had been overridden and the runtime type was unknown, you would need to dereference this to lookup do_it_if in the vtable, which would segfault in both tests.