How would you subtly add code to repositories without breaking git?
I guess the only protection against this would be to either never press the merge button in github, or repeat the merge locally and check there is no diff against the remote merge.
The reasoning is always that you are actually signing the whole commit chain because your commit is liked to every previous one by the commit hashes.
Of course on big projects a lot of the code isn't touched in years but we're talking about revealing that somebody broke SHA1. It sounds very risky given the stakes.