The problem is, these things were indicators, but they have been manipulated to be used as if they were proof.
If the suspect is a red head male, and the witness describes seeing a red head male, then the jury is inclined to think that's the same guy.
IT's human nature.
Even in New York City.
Where there are at least 84,000 red headed males!
Starting from that weak position, the FBI then ignores basic statistics:
http://freakonomics.com/2008/08/19/are-the-fbis-probabilitie...
The main problem is TV I guess, for the average guy, these kind of technologies are completely infallible and people tend to forget that just like anything else, it's just an indicator that can be fooled / misinterpreted / badly gathered.
I'll go polish my tinfoil hat now.
Yes, a strong preexisting demand and no way to fulfill it honestly. (Really, the first is doing most of the work.)
Same reason you get charlatans and incompetents in love spells, medicine, and longevity.