Turning Ethiopia's desert green
bbc.com
bbc.com
I joined her for the last 3 weeks, and so I got to know some of the guys that run these programs and the whole cultural UN/Worldbank etc. bubble. I came away impressed, the country itself is very under-developed, but these people (mostly) made a good impression. They try to do as much as possible on their own, and not relying too much on foreign expertise or leadership.
Its not exactly a democracy, and some programs are essentially forced labour, requiring villagers to work for free and build these terraces and irrigation etc., but it works and they have no money to do it any other way. Places where people used to starve are now food-secure.
It is also a great country to travel, violence is very rare and the food is really nice. It helped to eliminate lots of preconceptions I had.
http://www.unhcr.org/pages/49e483a16.html
See UNHCR 2015 Projection Figures for Kenya
Well it's not as though a democracy is absolutely the best either; there are all kinds of undesirable features like losing 49/51 and getting basically no say for the next four years. But I digress.
In the case where very little money changes hands (subsistence farming) then compulsory labor is a more effective tax than requiring cash payments. Any percentage of nothing is still nothing. And at only 20 days out of a notional 250 work day year, it's less than a 10% tax which seems incredibly reasonable compared to what people in the developed world pay, generally between 20% and 70% (or more) depending on country, state and city.
Well contrast that with dictatorships where the side with 95% support still loses, and it feels a lot better. This to me is the main feature of democracy. The second best option will occasionally win against the best one. But at least the terrible option will lose.
If you're curious like me, here are some pictures of the actual terraces: https://www.google.com/search?q=Tigray+terracing
It's important to be a bit cognizant of the political situations, though. The willful ignorance of Ethiopia's political reality when Live Aid happened led to piles of charity dollars essentially going straight to the Derg, and thus into arms deals to continue the war with Eritrea.
It's the article's use of the mid-1980s famines as a hook for discussing economic development as a technical land-use issue that makes the omission more glaring. And it would be a more interesting article, to consider the history of efforts to abolish feudal land tenure, for example. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_reform_in_Ethiopia
I'm curious about the use of compulsory collective agricultural labor that has made this possible, though ;)
This video has been posted before, and permaculture has been as well, but it's extremely relevant. Terracing takes "a lot" of work which is a downside. There are other downsides as well, but it's a formidable strategy when dealing with steep hills. The hill in the picture from the article actually looks swale-able, which would be a much better approach (more overall water saturation).
Next, what would we do with these people's agricultural output? The US government pays current farmers not to use land to keep food prices up. US have 721k farmers; Ethiopia has 86M population.
Talking about Tigray, with a population of 4.3 millions. I wonder if the equipment to farm to feed those people would actually weigh less than the people? A few thousand boat trips would serve to move them all. In fact, once a fraction had been moved, pressure would be reduce in Tigray to house and feed the remainder.
Remember America took in 65 Million people over its history. Most of those came by steam ship. Today it would be faster and cheaper by far.
I wonder if the equipment to farm to feed those people
would actually weigh less than the people
I would certainly think so, considering how advanced modern farming tech is (or even 50 years old farming tech). 4.3m people plus food/water/other stuff they need to survive a couple weeks on a ship (plus then transporting them overland to wherever) weighs A LOT, fuel & vessels to transport them are also not trivial.The farm equipment also doesn't have to come from America, there are far closer manufacturers (Israel is ~3000km by ship from Eilat, Europe or India ~1000-2000 more).
Anyway hauling millions of people over to America sounds like a pretty ridiculous solution to me. You think the US government would accept millions of refugees with open arms? Why did the majority of Iraqi war refugees had to come to Europe instead?
And the idea is more a speculative engineering question. What kind of solutions would be more efficient, IF ONLY politics didn't get in the way?
Not to mention it's at least slightly offensive & like treating people like cattle to move them around wholesale like that. Ultimately the problem is not the climate or soil it's the (mis)allocations of resources.
Again, the 'offensive' argument is political. Trying to just compare outcomes, to know what to shoot for in the political realm. Remember, these are already refugees, there against their will.
I think you really overestimate how harsh the climate in Ethiopia is - it's not like trying to colonize Mars or Arrakis. It's hardly the Sahara either. The climate is in fact less harsh than fairly extensive parts of the US (particularly the West).
[1] Israel was also doing quite well even when it was a fairly poor country in the 50s/60s (although it was never as dirt poor as Ethiopia).
To look at it another way, consider a village of 200 refugees. Instead of importing a tractor, mechanic, fuel supply route, parts, seed, education, engineering know-how etc.
Consider moving those 200 people to where the parts store is not 10,000 miles away. Arguably cheaper.
Most of America is uninhabited for instance. I heard once that everybody in China could fit in Montana easily. There're 100M acres in Montana, so maybe that's a stretch - 20 people supported by 1 acres is unlikely.
That's how modern rich countries like the USA can be net food exporters while employing less than 2% of the population (you will find similar figures in other developed countries). A village of 200 people in the middle of nowhere probably can't be fed by 4 farmers regardless of how much equipment they have.
So the argument "Move them to the West where modern
farming techniques are available" now becomes very,
very much more efficient that leaving them where they
are.
But the argument wasn't for "just leaving them where they are" - it was for bringing them modern farming techniques.The reason that wasn't done has more to do with politics and economics (in the sense that there isn't as much money to be made by doing so - same reason why nobody is going to spend billions/trillions bringing them to Montana).
But if you Were to spend money on improving their lot, then I'd much rather transport a culturally significant number of them to a convenient location where their efforts could leverage modern resources.