I, for one, like seeing the new heroes being introduced into the mix such as Guardians of the Galaxy and Ant-Man. Marvel has a large number of characters to rely on that haven't been introduced into the cinematic universe. Just because they are relatively unknown doesn't mean it won't work. Guardians was considered a risk because most people had no idea what they were, yet it did big numbers at the box office.
These stories can be told endlessly if they are done correctly. Not all of Marvel's characters are super-powered beings and some of the normal characters have interesting stories to tell. Daredevil on Netflix is a good example of this. It didn't even feel like a typical Marvel enterprise until the suit came into play. Up to that point it was an interesting drama with occasional action pieces. Agents of Shield is another; stories about mostly ordinary people dealing with living in this new world of super-beings and gods.
Where comic book movies/shows go wrong is when they are created to be commercials for selling toys and the story comes second. So far, Marvel has avoided this. Hopefully DC can do the same. If telling the story is always the most important aspect, then these things can last a long time before they get boring.
Why? For instance James Bond worked just fine with simply replacing whomever was playing Bond from time to time.
> You can only drag someone to see an origin story so many times.
But rebooting ends up simply retelling origin stories over and over. How many times do you need to tell how Superman (yes I know that's DC) or Batman (again, DC) or Spiderman became themselves, or how their villains became them.
Apparently it's every 10 years for Spiderman.
The actual actor for these parts shouldn't matter. That they play the character and in the continuity should. But maybe I'm missing something, I never really got into comic books.
I don't mind new actors, or re-boots. What I am worried about is 6 new movies coming out, and an origin story movie being half of them. Before it was one every 4-5 years, now it is one every two-years, pretty soon you get into a origin-movie-fatigue situation with two being made every year.
That could just be me, but who knows?
Audiences won't get bored as long as their are good stories to tell.
Based on a few 'superhero' examples, clearly, a reboot can work:
Box Office (in millions of dollars):
-Spiderman 2002: $821
-Spiderman 2012: $757
-Batman 1989: $411
-Batman Begins 2005: $374
-Hulk 2003: $245
-The Incredible Hulk 2008: $263
-Robocop 1987: $100
-Robocop 2014: $242
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r_X5C6e3ZeY
Shame it was never released. Apparently it was so bad they tried to erase it from history.
This isn't really that hard to avoid, you know? You just need someone with enough central authority to stop the writers from doing this. It's not clever or compelling storytelling, it's just complicated. Said central authority doesn't have to write the story, per se, just prevent this from happening.
I'd also observe there's abundant cinematic precedent for having to change actors, and the Hulk has already been changed without it being a reboot or "new character".
Handled carefully there's no reason this universe MUST become crufty, overpopulated, and stale. It's just... the natural thing that happens when you aren't careful.
And I have hope that they may be careful. One of the undercurrents of the article they never quite called out all the way is that the Hollywood blockbuster machine is broken. Look at how well Marvel is doing, and by and large, they're doing it on good, solid storytelling. Not uniformly across the board, no, but much better than the average blockbusters. Hollywood is apparently willing to pour millions upon millions into special effects but often appears to spend about "$5.12 + whatever the director has in his wallet" on story... or, more accurately, they treat the story like that's the investment they have in it. Marvel is not hitting it out of the park every time, but they clearly care more than the Hollywood machine. Right now, if there's anybody who can hold this all together without an endless series of reboots, it's the Marvel movie guys.
Then perhaps Wolverine can be true to the comic, womanizer and short 5'3''.