The art of butchery
aeon.co
aeon.co
The meat tastes really really good, and is much cheaper than buying it at the store-- For example, my ducks cost less than $4 each to raise, and the whole herd takes about 15 minutes of effort per day. I never thought of duck as 'poor person food' when I was a kid...
Butchering is a huge pain in the ass, but it's fundamentally similar to taking apart computers/machines etc. and doing butchery is a good way to practice your surgical technique, if you have to do that kind of stuff for work or whatever. The downside is that you might start getting hungry whenever you have to cut up rats.
I used to be into squirrels and rabbits-- Truly 'poor person food--' but have gotten increasingly paranoid about disease, as transmissible prion diseases have been 'tentatively reported' in squirrels [0] and tularemia is endemic in rabbits where I live [1].
[0] http://www.thelancet.com/pdfs/journals/lancet/PIIS0140-6736%...
On butchering side of things, raising around 100 birds a year for slaughter would be crazy for us. Going from a full vegan lifestyle a few years back to slaughtering and butchering some of our own food has been an interesting change. I would recommend it if you have second guessed any of the weirdness with how food makes it to your plate. It definitely gives you something to think about. Killing really cute ducks that we raised by hand was definitely tough in the beginning. I had never hunted or killed any animal on purpose before. It's always a bummer but it does get a little easier in time. We've got a bunch of our eggs in our incubator now, hoping for more ducks in 24 days!
The biggest difference is that you never have to put it back together again in a working state.
"The findings indicate that slaughterhouse employment increases total arrest rates, arrests for violent crimes, arrests for rape, and arrests for other sex offenses in comparison with other industries."
Industrial slaughter is vastly different to slaughtering your own.
And the correlation is easily explained - it's well-paid, difficult and unpleasant work, and it attracts men who tend to drink hard. Alcohol and crime correlate very well.
You're doing it wrong (I was lucky enough to have someone show me this when I was young [a long, long time ago]).
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4c8OyexZ10E
I haven't hunted in years. When I was young a friend's mom would fix our squirrels with home-made biscuits and gravy .. good times.
I learn so much on HN! I'll have to try this next time. Hopefully that wasn't some special breed of loose-skinned squirrel.
Rabbit was much better, but you had to be careful cleaning it (rabbit bladders can EXPLODE), and Dad hated rabbits... chasing rabbits is the worst habit a bird dog can develop.
For example, while you are eating a wing, count how many bones each part have and compare it with a (picture of a) human skeleton. Repeat this with a chicken leg and thigh. (Remember to count that thin bone as another bone.)
Almost all of the meat I cook is raised by someone I know and butchered by myself and/or folks I know. I've never been as satisfied with a piece of meat as I've been since I started participating in the processing. I highly recommend trying it if you know someone who can show you the ropes.
The way I read it, he was not saying "butchering made a connection between me and the animal I was butchering," but rather that "butchering helped me make a connection between the steak and the animal it came from."
That is to say, I understand him as saying that he now recognizes that a given cut of meat comes from a given place on an animal, rather than being just a piece of meat.
This isn't about having a connection with a particular animal, it's having a connection with the process.
Because I think it's just meat eater apologism. The issues with eating meat don't change if you do the killing yourself or in an artsy way.
"The way I see it, it's not that there's a desire for the blood and gore, but rather we’re hardwired to deal with the blood and gore, and when that innate machinery goes unused – as it does in a postdomestic society – humans are left with a gap, with something missing."
The fact that we're hardwired to crave something does not automatically imply we should do it. This is part of what being human is about. If men crave sex, it doesn't follow that they should rape women lest they are left with a gap or something missing. I used to love eating meat more than most people I know, but stopped eating it years ago since it didn't make any sense to me that for my pleasure a sentient animal should suffer and die. I have no trouble dealing with the gap...
Note that I'm not judgemental about my friends or any other people that eat meat. Life is not black and white - everyone can make their choices and I know vegetarians and vegans who can take morality lessons from meat eaters - but at least we should call a spade a spade. Unless it's crucial for your own survival, I believe eating meat brings more suffering than joy to the world.
Imagine a thought experiment in which you could either die painlessly, or live but be required to endure days or weeks of incredibly painful torture (for the purposes of the experiment let's say that it doesn't leave lasting physical/emotional damage).
I'd pick the torture. I assume most other people would too.
I think that should illustrate fairly well that the distinction between life and death is so much greater than that between joy and suffering.
The (somewhat simplified) options available are: 1. Raise and slaughter animals in the most convenient and/or economically efficient way without regards for their suffering. (standard meat way) 2. Raise and slaughter animals in the most humane and painless way without regard for economic cost. (omnivore's dilemma way) 3. Do not raise any animals. Eat a 100% plan based diet. (vegan way).
There is no scenario where animals can trade enduring pain for anything. We are talking about domestic animals. They are born because we facilitated it, with the expectation of a gain from such activity.
I can see why people would want to be vegan, and while I do not share those opinions I respect them. But, if everybody thought like that, most domestic animal species would go extinct in a few decades. Most people would stop raising them, and if a few misguided folks would release flocks in the wild, those are in general not prepared to occupy an ecologic niche. They will either die off or wreck the environment of the region they were released at.
So, between options 1 and 2. The animals are going to die anyways, because if we did not expected to eat them, nobody would have bothered raising them. The only question left is how much suffering are they to endure in the process of dying. Proponents of #1 say this does not matter as long as the plate is full. Proponents of #2 say it is morally right to eat less meat in order to ensure the animals get killed in a more humane way.
How does your previous comment fits in that debate?