College for the masses
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
First of all, the actual pool of bona fide middle class jobs is quite small as far as I can see. Being able to shop at Waitrose is not interesting. If you have no net worth and your parents have no net worth you are not middle class.
A mortgage in London on a 1BR flat with the maximum reasonable commute requires a 50K annual income.
Outside of the capital; similar situation but with the numbers scaled down. There are jobs that exist paying this well, yes, but they are certainly not common.
That is to say that graduating is not necessarily good enough. It might be a good result, or good internships, or talent, or prestige (e.g. an elite university).
Income inequality is not the issue; wealth inequality is (specifically, the middle class now sits on levels of wealth that look intergenerational from where I stand).
College should not be pulled in to this. College should be about education. About helping people to appreciate and understand this world we have around us. About making adults out of children.
The capitalist economy is broken for youth today. Sending them to college won't fix that except for a tiny privileged few.
When we drive millions more poor people to college, the average value of a college degree will go down. Then we will come up with some new institution that is the "ticket to the middle class," like getting a masters degree. Back in the 1970s, you could get a job with a high school diploma. Now, you have to go to college, work a few unpaid internships, hope you can get an OK job.
Social mobility is a distraction. It's not a real solution. It's political language; it assumes the underlying system.
A system that cycles people around from being poor to rich based on merit is not a good system, because merit is essentially arbitrary (beyond deliberate antisocial behaviour).
I have a talent, my friend does not, I get to live the good life, he gets a lifetime of insecure rental accomodation or homelessness. (True story.)
It just does not work. It's based on an outdated idea of work ethic, it assumes people have more control over their faculties than they actually do.
I can live with a system that has people competing for sports cars, yachts and jets. Those things don't matter. But having people fight to put a roof over their head is just nonsensical in wealthy countries like the UK/USA. It's a holdover from the Industrial Revolution and the wealthy's desire to force people to labour.
Here's the kicker! Everyone thinks that the current form of capitalism is good. Right from childhood (at least in the US) the American system of capitalism is drilled into children's minds as the best thing there can be (perhaps even God's chosen system of similar bullcrap)
And then when they get to college, they're indoctrinated into the exact opposite ideology by marxist/socialist professors into your line of thinking.
Personally, I want reality to be presented the way it is instead of constant self-glorification.
A system that cycles people around from being poor to rich based on merit is not a good system, because merit is essentially arbitrary (beyond deliberate antisocial behaviour).
Essentially, absolutely, a luck of the cards of who you know or who you gamed to think you have merit? Pretty cynical with obvious ideological connotations..especially the anti-social behavior part.
But having people fight to put a roof over their head is just nonsensical in wealthy countries like the UK/USA.
You use the word "fight". Fight would presume that there's some motivation involved. Many people increasingly don't have motivation and are copping out with "disability".
It's a holdover from the Industrial Revolution and the wealthy's desire to force people to labour.
Wealthy people tend to supply the jobs, but they don't have the guns to force people to do anything. The government has the guns to force people.
It seems instead of looking through this perspective, the whole endeavour is viewed as making an investment and reaping monetary gains thereafter. Of-course then the service providers and lenders want their piece of pie. Currently the system is designed for goal that does not match its true objective. Its broken in that sense.
One idea often mentioned is to maintain the current model by limiting the college education to select few who really deserve it. Instead of this regressive view, the economic aspect of college education needs to be addressed.
"College graduates are also healthier, happier, more likely to remain married, more likely to be engaged parents and more likely to vote, research has found."
Much of discourse surrounding college has been the economics. Arguably, it is hard to justify the cost of $200k price tag + $200k opportunity cost for a top-tier university, and come out with a $40-60k/year job. But college isn't just about crafting yourself to a job market. You get to truly explore who you are with a diverse group of people (race, genders, sexualities, culture, political leanings, economic backgrounds, drug habits) near your age, all while having access to all the knowledge of the world (be it religion, history, art, economics, etc).
Is the SJW culture of thought police hurting what makes college awesome? Yes. Is there a huge bloat of administrators that drives up the cost of college education? Yes. Are certain humanities departments misleading students into thinking that they can get a job with their degree? Yes. Do less-social students get less out of college? Yes.
But is college completely worthless? Of course not.
I don't think it's particularly off the wall to say that some things just don't have a price or a monetary reward. Capitalism is a fun game that we play that works in some areas and doesn't in others; it's not the meaning of life.
Should I read Shakespeare in my free time or work on a side project? Should I paint or look out of the window at the wildlife or should I move further from work and spend that time commuting?
Capitalism makes sense for producing widgets at low cost. For apportioning scarce luxury objects. Etc. But we don't win by trying to make everything profitable. We just make everything more competitive, more stressful, less... human.
But Capitalism also allows people a great degree more freedom to do the things they want. Are there constraints? Sure. Is it perfect? Clearly not. But there are many who justify themselves by the works they produce. I don't ordinarily think of myself as that, but when I was an electrician, I used to construct things, build things.
I still get a sense of pride whenever I'm home and can look at the light poles that I jackhammered the foundations from, directed the concrete pouring of, wired to main, erected with a crane and bolted into place. There's an odd sense of pride that I have every time I see them. That's something I did. And yeah, it's pretty trivial, but I get value from it.
In a capitalist system, not only can I prioritize how much I choose to work, but I also have the luxury of choosing what I do, where I can contribute the most value. I can't say that I've studied it very much, but compared to assigned work for whatever the normal amount of pay is, I very much prefer the freedom of working more for more money, or working less for less money, in a field of my choosing.
I can then allocate that money to the items I prioritize most dearly to me. I never have as new a phone as my peers seem to, but in their stead, I have some very nice guitars that I gain great enjoyment from.
I'm not yet convinced that there a non-capitalist system exists that affords me such choices. Without incentivizing at least some people to go out and get work done, it seems unlikely to me that there is wealth enough to sustain our collective frivolities. And sure, looking out the window doesn't cost a whole lot, but guitars do, and so do canvases and paints.
For example, after world war two, the top tax rate was 90% and the world didn't end. This decimated the concentrations of wealth at the upper reaches of society and excessive luxury spending plummeted (for instance, once basic needs are satisfied, rich people start trading around excessively expensive pieces of art or excessively large houses). It, amongst other policies, also broke the intergenerational passage of wealth. However, it didn't remove the temptation to still create wealth. Think of it like playing a game on hard mode, you only get 1/10th the points a n00b gets, but you can still increase your relative position compared to others (which is what I assume rich people really care about when it comes to personal finances).
I'm not advocating a particular course of action, but it seems the current course is unsustainable and similar things have been done successfully before. The political rhetoric is out of control these days though.
Also, for what it's worth, guitars and canvases don't really cost that much. ;)
EDIT: Thinking about this, what if we explicitly posed tax rates as validations of people's success and allowed them to get "achievements" past a certain point? Then playing the game at a harder difficulty would be a badge of prestige. This sounds a little crazy here, but in, e.g. the netherlands has entirely public tax returns and it's been debated and enacted here at various times: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/02/14/business/yourtaxes/14discl...
No, but it also wasn't nearly as easy then to emigrate to another country. Considering that the rich can file a few forms and gain citizenship in a tax-friendlier haven, and that is all that is required to recoup some 50% of their earnings, it seems unlikely that wealth would continue to be concentrated in America. Though expatriation numbers are relatively low overall, the rate of expatriation is currently at record highs. So long as there are countries not charging 90% tax rates, it seems unlikely that tax revenues would climb significantly, especially considering that the effective tax revenues stays relatively constant, it seems unlikely to change all that much.
As far as all that goes, if you're not talking about supplanting capitalism, then it seems like we can agree that capitalism isn't actually Satan incarnate. If the "fix" for Capitalism is more of what we have (since we do already have redistribution, in spades), then we aren't talking about changing the game at all, but perhaps just some of the rules.
As for the unsustainability of the current course, what, in particular, indicates that the current course is doing so horribly? We had a giant bust, and a slowly recovering recession, but that doesn't necessarily put capitalism as the culprit. I look at Twitter, and I see #resistcapitalism trending, and it seems everybody's trying to blame capitalism for police brutality. Maybe I'm just missing the bigger picture, but I can't figure out how the two are linked, even just a little bit.
This is a cool video I saw a while back that shows the current issue: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QPKKQnijnsM
I also agree that movement between countries is a modern problem that probably invalidates the old solution (unless multiple countries coordinate - unlikely). So, we have a problem that wealth will continue to concentrate absent controls on the distribution.
The US has a lot of political problems right now, and the major commonality is that people at the bottom get the shaft every time. I think it's too much to try to solve every problem facing civilization in one conversation though, so I'll stick to distributions. ;)
For what it's worth, believe me, I'm not a hippie. I want to start a company and get rich one day like all of you. I just think it's important to pay attention to the steady state of the system we are participating in.
A roof and basic food are not.
That's really the issue I have with our version of capitalism - that we use the same token for two drastically different classes of goods. That it infects everything.
I think you're arguing against a strawman here really. I don't take issue with the idea of some people earning fantastically more than others. I have a problem when the bottom level is in squalor.
To my understanding, history has shown that bringing the top down doesn't necessarily take the bottom up along with it. If my understanding is flawed, then by all means, feel free to illustrate how.
You can have capitalism without everything being a free market. We already do.
As I said, the issue is with our implementation. It doesn't make sense for land to be fully subjected to a free market because the endgame is fairly obviously lords and serfs. The same doesn't happen elsewhere really.
If the state built homes until there were enough for everyone and then we played capitalism with food and cars and trains and skateboards and yachts and TVs and the Internet and all of those other things higher up the hierarchy of needs, would you not consider that capitalism?
You'd still have returns on capital, you'd still have people owning more or less land. You'd still have bigger and smaller homes.
But you might not be able to force (or heavily nudge towards) people into wage slavery. :)
Because this whole thread started with the assertion that "The capitalist economy is broken for youth today", so the assumption is that fixes are to move away from capitalism.
"If the state built homes until there were enough for everyone"
You can probably skip that step, and just rewrite the rules for adverse possession. America currently has more vacant homes than there are homeless people. In fact, if we wanted, we could give six vacant homes to each homeless person, let them pick the one they like the best, and give back the other five. It absolves the taxpayer obligation to maintain the homes (which isn't really being met anyway), puts the homeless in homes, and doesn't really have too much in the way of perverse incentives, but for the invariability that we might temporarily grow the homeless population for those looking for free homes.
I don't know how that fixes wage slavery in any meaningful way though, as having a home doesn't positively correlate to having a job. The problem of poverty right now is lack of full time employment. There's not really any fix for wage slavery that is predicated on capitalism, if capitalism is to have any actual meaning, anyway. I mean, there's minimum wage, but while it's easy to acknowledge that there's no direct correlation between minimum wage and unemployment, OECD companies with the highest minimum wages tend to have the highest rates of unemployment. Unemployment very positively correlates with poverty, house or not.
There's an argument to be made that if housing were free, that the minimum wage could be abolished, but that doesn't sound like something you'd support.
I don't really want to engage with the rest because I feel 'poverty' is too vague a word to use in this context.
Owning a home and having to be careful with what you eat and about whether you can turn the lights on is a very different state of existence compared to eating roughly whatever you want but worrying about making the rent. The latter makes you a serf to a lord, the former is a struggle. They are both difficult but their effect on the psyche is differebt.
Why should diversity be about everything except age? Is regimenting young people by age really doing a service?