How could it possibly be true that in the 100 years between 1770 and 1870, the fastest milers lost a full 30 seconds (25% performance decrease)[1]? How could it be that men like Thomas Horspool[2] were widely recognized as champions and world record holders while running so much slower than amateurs from only half a century before?
Anyone who has trained seriously on the track would know the type of all-encompassing effort--nutrition, sleep, physical therapy, training--and modern science--VO2Max, heart rate, running economy [3]--that go into training for a four-minute mile. The idea that people were doing all of that in Britain in the 18th century is laughable.
[1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/timeline/d3c109a21... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Horspool [3] http://sportsscientists.com/2007/12/running-economy-part-i/