Contrast this with an individual or startup, where the technology decision maker has a vested interested in its usability.
Contrast this with an individual or startup, where the technology decision maker has a vested interested in its usability.
IT departments are trying to maximize aggregate efficiency across the organization (which includes themselves). While it might marginally increase productivity of office staff if they're allowed to choose whatever mail client they're used to, it is going to require a considerable investment in IT staff to support it.
Please keep in mind that an office full of programmers is absolutely not the norm. While programmers and engineers might hate the evil IT department, most offices wouldn't be able to exist without their mean policies.
Man, talk about inflammatory. Offices have existed for centuries without mean IT policies. I'm not even sure how to read your comment in such a way that it models ANY reality.
Are you suggesting that we do away with computers in the workplace?
Unfortunately, the IT systems that people use in their offices, and the people supporting said systems are compliments to one another.
Just as IT departments often don't have usability as a primary concern, the corporation itself often doesn't have technical fitness as a concern. To them, almost all technology decisions are dominated by the concern of corporate risk.
They want industry-standards, because it keeps cog replacement costs down. They want you to use their gear to minimize data security concerns. They want to shut down youtube, lest they appear to be not enforcing the harassment policy. They force IE6 because they're trying to meet return projections on bad investments from years ago. They provide a standardized environment so they can shuffle cogs more easily. Etc.
Even if the average user always chose the best available tool, even if they were security-conscious, studiously making regular backups and vigilantly updating their software - corporate concerns would still regularly trump their desire to have X.
Just pick an IT guy and ask him how much say he has in what software he has to use all day.
(See Paypal ignoring all the banking regulation - figuring they'd get big/bought first)