Respected developers begin fleeing from App Store platform
arstechnica.com
arstechnica.com
- Apple unreasonably rejects applications.
- It takes 2 to 3 weeks to be told you've been rejected, and even then you only are given one reason even if there are several problems that need to be addressed.
My overall impression is that most of the complaints about the first point are simply due to the frustration borne of the second. It's not the rejection over the stupidest things that stings, it's the fact that you had to wait forever to be told "you need to change your icon." Then, after your five minute fix, it's back in the hopper for another three weeks. All the while competitors appear in the App Store, clients get pissed, and cash burns.
It's incredible to me that the embarassingly parallel problem of app approval wait time has not only been left unsolved, but has apparently gotten worse.
Imagine if the turnaround time on these things dropped from 3 weeks to a few hours. Being rejected would turn from a devestating event to a minor inconvenience, and I'd imagine that all this bad press would evaporate. Sure, you'd have some developers complain that their apps would never be approved due to impasses between them and Apple in terms of service violations, but I think these folks would be in the minority since most violations can be fixed once you're made aware of them.
I think the reason why it takes two weeks is that some developers submit new version as soon as the last one is approved just to enjoy the ratings of "new stuff".
A better model would be to allow developers rolling 24 updates per year, and you can chose how to spend them. This would prevent the spam problem and allow updates to publish quickly once they are done.
Personally I now publish new update the moment last one is approved (provided I have anything new at all), for a simple reason - it's better to submit any feature for approval however small ASAP than wait for it to be rejected when I really wanted to ship large bucket of features.
I don't blame you. That's a perfectly rational response and everybody should follow your strategy if they know what's good for them. It's Apple's fault for creating the incentive structure wherein that's the locally-optimal strategy.
As far as solutions, I like the pay-per-app model the best. The signal-to-noise ratio in the app store is way too high (low?). It doesn't need to be too expensive to publish an app, it just needs to deter the kinds of publishers that are writing one app and rebranding it hundreds of times (per sports team, per state, etc). You even have people taking public domain novels and throwing thousands of them up as $0.99 ebooks, just on the chance that the sheer volume of them will make a profit. There are of course thousands of great apps, too, but the chances of stumbling across any of them are becoming smaller and smaller.
Think of it like a fraction. Signal/noise. Signal divided by noise. I assume you were saying it was a low fraction. :)
Good post, by the way, I hope Apple steals your idea.
Apple is going to have to work hard to turn this boat around, at this point their only real choice might be to open the platform.
Apple has a lot to answer for, but I am wondering if the price a developer pays ($99 a year) is too low and if Palm's pay per app ($99 year + $50 per app) a more realistic model to pay for more people to review apps?