Businesses which are caught doing something dodgy pay - at most - the amount they would have had to pay to obey the law. And the chance of being caught is not exactly high.
Businesses which are caught doing something dodgy pay - at most - the amount they would have had to pay to obey the law. And the chance of being caught is not exactly high.
If "cost of getting caught" is always less than "amount you save from breaking the law", then there's no reason to behave honestly. In fact, this causes the "market" to select against corporations run by honest people, because they're at a competitive disadvantage.
Your formula gives you positive Expected Value but there are many situations that are +EV which you shouldn't choose to visit.
Even if the penalty was more than you were saving (or if the penalty hit nominally responsible individuals), even if the chance were fairly low, that could act as a significant deterrant to unethical practices.
Situation: "ooh should I talk to my actuary/lawyer/partner about this difficult unethical decision? Arg but that would leave a paper trail."
Actually, if you talk about it with your lawyer, attorney-client privilege protects you. Just make sure you do it in person and aren't dumb enough to do it by E-Mail.
Though I suppose the chances of something like that would be even less than such folks seeing jail time, which would also be a non-financial punishment.
For this context a financial punishment is appropriate ("punishment should fit the crime"). And the existence of the formula above is actually helpful. It makes it simple to figure out exactly what the punishment amount should be, whereas flogging as a deterrent is a tad harder to measure, and as you point out, is barbaric.
As long as the fines are only coming from the company the only one you're really punishing are the shareholders who really have no control over the company's day to day activities and these decisions. They have no visibility into this either.
The CEO should be held responsible for any illegal activities the company undertakes under his direction as should the directors. Assuming they're aware of it. Otherwise the responsibility is probably at some lower level. This does not contradict the responsibility of the company as a legal entity which is a party to these contract.
EDIT: A decision that may cost the company 100M in fines in 10 years and help the CEO make his bonus this year is a no brainer. This is not unlike deciding to do share buybacks when you hold stock options...