I think it's a faulty generalization either way, companies should be run by competent passionate people.
I think it's a faulty generalization either way, companies should be run by competent passionate people.
I agree that MBAs aren't a bad thing, and HP had many for a lot of years before Carly. But I would argue that it's exceptionally hard to change a company culture so drastically. And it can he detrimental to the organization as a whole.
Ferdinand Piëch said in his autobiography:
"[The leader] must have a technical background, as a development- or production technician. He has to have an integral (not quickly acquired) passion for cars and be able to think ten years ahead. The technical foundation is required in order to develop the necessary phantasy."
I think the "develop the necessary phantasy" is the interesting part, as I think this matches Steve Job's approach, too. No engineer could bullshit him, because he knew exactly what was possible. He knew when it was possible to build the iPhone, when the RIM CEOs didn't even believe it when it was revealed to the world.
You were very lucky in your meetings with MBAs.
> A lot of MBA programs are structured to teach business acumen to folks that didn't take a 4 year business / commerce degree to start with..
Yeah, and in most cases they didn't take a 4 year engineering degree either.