A digital skeleton key to access any website
docs.higg.so
docs.higg.so
Your "ultimate solution" will just become another on top of the "ultimate solutions" listed as the services you indicated on your post.
Your idea seems too narrow to address a mass-market.
The tools that exist are already serving niches:
- Bugmenot - to bypass signups where something important is needed behind the signup-wall but probably not an account you'd use for amazon.com
- Quick signups = social login . Most people are content to connect to sites via Google/Facebook login, which avoids the entire signup process
- Lastly, don't forget OpenID - it died recently and was an attempt to unify the login process. Probably exactly the use-case for you.
Truth be told, site-makers have signups because they can and do so because they want to capture data from users for "important" advertising, user-data-selling, etc.
So long as users are happy to sacrifice some data for a 'free' service, this is the model the internet will continue to thrive on and signups will continue.
If you want to go ahead and try to solve the problem for yourself, it may be worth it. For the average user though, this is another non-problem in their quest to use x-social-cool-new-app that requires me to just login via Facebook to so I can "share" stuff.
Good luck!
1. The NASCAR problem. Listing out every popular service does not guide the user through the login process.
2. The lost NASCAR problem. I know I signed up with one of these services but which one for this site?
3. The abandoned service problem. How do I access this site after my identity provider closed shop or the service I was using decided to stop supporting OpenID?
4. The redirection dialog problem. What do all these dialogs mean and what access am I granting to who?
5. The phishing problem. The default experience lends itself to teaching people to type secrets into popups / redirects coming from other sites.
6. Nobody wants to be a URL; email is king here. The support for email came late in the game.
7. The double registration problem. I signed up with OpenID which gives the site my basic profile but I still have to "finish" registration by giving more information.
There are many other issues but those are the big ones to me.
<link rel="openid.server" href="https://indieauth.com/openid" />
<link rel="openid.delegate" href="http://mynamedomain.com/" />OpenID has gone the same way as XMPP, a good open and decentralised protocol lost to proprietary social networks.
https://stackexchange.com/users/login https://bitbucket.org/account/signin/ http://openid.yahoo.com/ still responds, surprisingly. The wordpress openid plugin is still around.
I'd say about half, probably more, of the web sites I log into are able to hold the session for an extended period of time. A few are very aggressive about expiring cookies and often it's because my IP address changes. Those sites are also ones that deal with frequent spamming or DDoS.
On the other hand, frequently having to login helps me remember my passwords. I can tell you right now I probably won't get into HN on the first try because I haven't had to type the password here for over a year.
Self-destructing cookies to purge cookies from closed tabs after a timeout is also a useful extension.
Why the fuck would any service provider want to make it easy for spammers to automate mass registrations as the author seems to want?
It's literally the reason CAPTCHA was invented.
Given that, why wouldn't website providers take active steps to block this?
I'd say browser auto compete solves 85% of this issue. The last 15% his the law of diminishing returns pretty quickly.
If I do it right, to a live human it will appear that the internet is just a little slow at the time.
>"The introduction of a National Postcode System, known as "Eircode", is planned to take place in Summer 2015."
>"An Post did not introduce automated sorting machines until the 1990s. By then, the optical character recognition (OCR) systems were advanced enough to read whole addresses, as opposed to just postcodes, thereby allowing An Post to skip a generation. Consequently, mail to addresses in the rest of the state does not require any digits after the address."
Yes, sites have different flows for signup. This is not a "problem". Different sites want different things, or have different needs. Some with have Captcha, others will require CC, or what have you.
Yes, there are some sites that require login and are just being asshats for it. And for those, bugmenot is good.
But for others, there is a need for signup. And that shouldn't be swept under the rug.
I think a better approach could be to push for more usability and accessibility of the forms. Because thats something I am all for.
Keep in mind, there are inherent problems like T.O.S breaching so the tool would have to deal with them the right way, and through the right channels. Perhaps a standard could be implemented and sites could 'opt in' to having the skeleton key used on their site. So yeah - like open source infrastructure too.
If the former, I think the opt-in is a dead end. If the websites thought that was good for them, they'd enable anonymous use, and it even might be illegal for them to cooperate (e.g. they would be breaking COPPA by offering a way for under-13 to use the site without following the proper steps).
As an end-user of sites I don't find registration a particularly onerous or annoying problem - signup, login, move along.
As an operator of a few different sites the concept of users spamming the crap out of my registration system using automation is an annoyance I could do without.
Now i understand why many sites don't want to use SSO's, they lose control over their user base and get much less information from a registration via SSO than they would via their own registration form, and always the SSO providers (e.g. Twitter and LinkedIn) can always say you know what we don't want to provide that service any more, and in many cases you can be left with no ability to recover a large part of your user base.
That said I haven't seen many sites that Chrome cannot populate virtually their entire sign up page from memory, and like most stuff in Chrome it's also (can be) shared between devices as long as you are signed into one. Heck not that i would advise it but Chrome can even store your credit card number "securely" although that option i believe does not replicate between devices (never used it myself, not crazy:)).
Yes sign up processes can be annoying, especially when they obviously unnecessary, but from experiences the sites that put everything behind a signup wall rarely have much content to offer in the first place, since sites that actually want to monetize their user based tend to have very easy signups in order to reduce drop out rate. Heck just look at payday loaners, their sign up is as short as possible to get some info about you for a credit check and that's it, they don't want people to drop off before they get a loan and every step increases the chance that they'll figure out that taking one at 123514% APR isn't the best solution for their financial shortcomings.
If my OS or Chrome is compromised I have bigger things to worry about than my credit card number, for which charges can easily be reversed...
And even in such cases when the exploitation is persistent it's still a question of how much can they get and in what time window since you might detect it and remediate the situation.
I've seen some sneaky tactics that some sites used to get details from auto complete functions of browsers, yes chrome asks you if you want to submit that data, and asks you specifically for your CC but if you mask some fields such as address and phone number (Chrome detects if it's hidden, and to some extent when its not visible due to other factors so it needs to be just cleverly disguised in rendering) when some one just auto-fills say their email and username it might also leak personal information, and if people are not too careful also they're payment data (which i believe Chrome only auto-fills on sites you visited before, and on secure connections).
I personally only have to input my CC details online every couple of months since i use PayPal or Amazon Checkout for about 90-95% of my purchases, so i rather not have my CC data stored on my machine if i can avoid it. Yes if it's compromised they can eventually get it, but it's still better than it being stored in a place where every malware on the planet knows to look for it.
On sites where I post or buy stuff, why would I want shared accounts? Maybe I can see it for software support sites. But even there, account reputation can be important.
I do get that registration can be a pain. But what I'd want wouldn't be a skeleton key, but rather a personal master key. Logins using Facebook and Google have become common.
But, being a privacy geek, I don't have accounts. And I definitely don't do cellphone authentication, because that is nontrivial to anonymize. However, I would want two-factor authentication. That's the tough problem, I think.
We need a better web of trust where another service can verify the identity of me as a user. Already with the likes of Chrome, much of my logins are already auto-filled meaning the browser is already happy with my identity, why can't part of this be used for signups. We have second-factor authentication, again why can't we leverage this to verify I am the real person. Between the browser, a third party service and the receiving service we can securely verify an identity without the need for passwords, email addresses and real names.
accounts that are used by groups are harder to track and pinpoint, and their site usage will likely be too random to glean meaningful data from them.
Depending on the size and scope of the skeleton key system, there could even be (very willing) people ready to solve them in exchange for a small fee. There's a startup if I saw one. Users of the skeleton key system could go premium if they want to bypass captcha systems and a portion of the money goes to the captcha-solver. Probably not a new idea, as I've seen many such nefarious systems in place for spam, except this would be legitimized!
Maybe you just need an app that signs you up for sites.