That's four assertions about his source, and none of them indicate that the source had any official role in the lead up to or the execution of the mission -- or, indeed, that he was even active in the IC at the time. That, plus the source's use of Vietnam-era terminology, suggests he could have started his career in the 1960s or very early 1970s, and thus could be at least five and as much as 10-15 years retired from the IC (assuming he had a full career at the Agency), and relying on contacts still active in the community for his information. The only statement that indicates the source had access to primary-source docs regards the SEALs' AARs, and even then it's impossible to be certain that Hersh's phrasing actually means that.
In this, Hersh is starting to remind me of many conservative writers who relied on similar source of often dubious quality -- Michael Ledeen's close connections with SISMI (now AISE) being one example, or the network of former CIA officers who whiled away the post-Stansfield Turner years running private intelligence shops and flowing questionable allegations to the National Review.
If Hersh is right -- and "right" in this case, given the explosive nature of his allegations, doesn't even mean in the ballpark, just playing the same game -- then this story is huge, the sort of thing that would forever color Obama's place in history and would probably bring Hillary's political hopes crashing to ground. But extraordinary claims require &c., and the fact that Hersh had to publish this in the LRB rather than The New Yorker or WaPo (both regular outlets for many of his scoops) indicates that their editors were very uncomfortable with his sourcing as well.
would probably bring Hillary's political hopes crashing to ground
Here we disagree. To put it crudely: NOBODY GIVES A FUCK!
Let's look at something IMO much more serious, Hillary's prowess at trading commodities.[1] She supposedly makes a cash deposit of under $1,000 into a trading account, and through a series of quite astute trades walks away with about $100,000 (about $323,000 in today's money) in about ten months, all as part-time activity.
As someone summarized it:
Only four explanations can account for
these remarkable results.
1) Blair may have been an exceptionally
good trader.
2) Hillary Clinton may have been
exceptionally lucky.
3) Blair may have been front-running
other orders.
4) Or Blair may have arranged to have a
broker fraudulently assign trades to
benefit Clinton's account.
Unless she was one of the greatest "amateur" commodities traders of all time, this was nothing more than a bribe to the Governor and First Lady of Arkansas.But, like I said, NOBODY GIVES A FUCK. As Wikipedia put it: "There were no official investigations of the trading and Clinton was never charged with any wrongdoing."
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hillary_Rodham_cattle_futures_...
Did you read the Wiki? Someone did some calculations of the "luck" involved:
Using a model that was stated to give the
hypothetical investor the benefit of the doubt,
they concluded that the odds of such a return
happening were at best 1 in 31 trillion
For comparison, current Powerball odds are a mere 1 in 175 million. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Powerball#Payout_and_oddsLottery wins are incredibly unlikely too, and yet people win them.
So manyittle things wrong here that I can't give any credit to anything in this dumb article
Few in the US are going to care either way. Osama is dead. How it happened doesn't really matter.