Better would be something like "Leaked email archive allegedly calls into question the integrity of a few climate scientists". Better still would be "62MB of climate science emails leaked; here are some alarming quotations" or something.
Better would be something like "Leaked email archive allegedly calls into question the integrity of a few climate scientists". Better still would be "62MB of climate science emails leaked; here are some alarming quotations" or something.
I disagree. If they are not following the scientific method, but fudging their data to agree with their pre-determined conclusions, they are not scientists.
2. I appreciate the rhetorical point you're making, but I prefer to distinguish between "not a scientist", "bad scientist" and "evildoing scientist". (But I do agree that if someone's found to have been falsifying results, whatever scientific work they've done is of little use to anyone unless there's some reliable way to disentangle the fraudulent and non-fraudulent bits.)
I earlier submitted a parallel article with pretty much the title that you suggested, and it went nowhere:
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=952082
Leaked FOIA files 62 mb of gold
Even before me, 'ellyagg' submitted an even closer parallel with a non-sensational title. It also has not garnered any discussion:http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=951915
Climate News: Hadley CRU hacked with release of hundreds of docs and emails
So while I personally will continue to submit with the title of the original article rather than bait, one could argue that having a discussion is better than not having a discussion.