YouTube pulls a Hulu -- yanking API access from TV-connected devices
engadget.com
engadget.com
I claim the essential difference is whether or not you're sitting on a couch when you watch it. Good luck writing a contract that bans that.
I know tons of people who connect a Mac Mini to their TV, too.
I don't own a TV, just a MacBook connected to an external screen that my couch is pointed at. I watch Hulu on it. I guess my screen doesn't have any kind of receiver for cable or anything though.
Obviously, the real problem is that the API-based access is ad-free. It is not really that surprising that Google would prevent the circumvention of its ads.
I wonder if alternate schemes such as PlayOn will continue to work? Using PlayOn, I can still watch Hulu on my PCH. They have a YouTube plugin, but I am guessing that they are relying upon the same API that the MSP folks used.
I thought their goal was to eventually insert video ads into videos; that goal will not be impacted by people watching videos on TV.
And it can't be copyright concerns either.
That being said, the points made elsewhere in the thread about the line being blurry are valid. My phone (HTC Touch Pro 2) has TV out and explicitly lists YouTube as a video source for that TV out. Does that count?
This also reinforces my hypothesis that going with "toy" boxes like roku, popcorn hour,etc. are a bad idea. We don't need to dumb down the hardware that's connected to our tv, but adapt it's purpose/interface. We have "OS'" for our 3 inch screens. We need one for our 50 inch screens.
But my 7yo can operate it with no problems. It doesn't (hasn't) crash, and I don't have to screw around with it like I would a MythTV system.
The only downside is cost; I think it cost like $500 a few years ago. (It's a Core 2 Duo mac mini.)