This is not at all the same situation.
The relationship governments have with their citizens is unique.
It goes like this: give us a chunk of your entire income forever or else we'll throw you in prison. Don't like it? Say good-bye to all your friends and family and enjoy surviving in a country where you don't understand anything anyone is saying, which will probably just give you the same ultimatum.
That's simply mafia-style protection-money robbery.
There is another option: voluntary association and voluntary taxation. This is just one possible form it can take: http://groupcurrency.org